KINGSTOWN, St. Vincent, Feb 16, CMC – The human rights organisation, Equal Rights, Access and Opportunities SVG Inc. (ERAO SVG) Friday said it is “disappointed” that the High Court has dismissed the case brought by two gay St. Vincent and the Grenadines nationals living overseas, challenging the the island’s buggery and gross indecency law.
In a statement, the ERAO SVG said that the consolidated cases by Javin Johnson and Sean Macleish had been filed in 2019 challenging sections 146 and 148 of St. Vincent and the Grenadines’ Criminal Code, titled “Buggery” and “Indecent practices between persons of the same sex” respectively.
The two men also contended that they were forced to leave or were expelled from the S. Vincent and the Grenadines by reason of the buggery and gross indecency laws and how they were allegedly treated while in the country or socially conditioned as a result.
Justice Esco Henry in her ruling held that the men had no legal standing to bring the claims, filed by Javin Johnson and Sean Macleish, in light of the fact that they live overseas and have not lived in St. Vincent and the Grenadines for some time.
She also dismissed the men’s argument that they had been forced to leave here because of their sexual orientation. The court also upheld the government’s argument that the laws are reasonably required for public health and morality.
But the ERAO SVG said this decision breaks recent trends in independent anglophone Caribbean countries where laws criminalizing private consensual same-sex relations between adults have been declared unconstitutional.
“To date, independent anglophone Caribbean countries where laws criminalizing private consensual same-sex relations between adults have been declared unconstitutional are Belize, Trinidad and Tobago, Antigua and Barbuda, St. Kitts and Nevis, and Barbados. “
It said currently, apart from St. Vincent and the Grenadines, laws criminalizing private consensual same-sex relations between adults still exist in Jamaica, Dominica, St. Lucia, Grenada, and Guyana.
“This is sad day for LGBTQ+ rights in St. Vincent and the Grenadines. Internationally and regionally, laws similar to those challenged in these cases have been declared unconstitutional and in violation of the rights of LGBTQ+ persons,” said attorney Jeshua Bardoo, the founder and executive officer of ERAO SVG.
“These archaic and draconian colonial laws, though not strictly enforced, symbolically denigrate LGBTQ+ persons as second-class citizens in their own country and perpetuate prejudice and stigma against them.”
Barboo said as a result, over the years, many LGBTQ+ persons here have faced physical, verbal, and emotional abuse, family violence and rejection, dropped out of school, homelessness, unemployment, workplace harassment, bullying, and sexual violence including rape and sexual harassment.
“They have suffered mistreatment from family, neighbors, coworkers, classmates, teachers, strangers, and even police officers. Due to the violence, harassment, and discrimination, many LGBTQ+ persons in St. Vincent and the Grenadines have migrated, sought out asylum and/or refugee status in other countries.
“LGBTQ+ Vincentians exist. You can’t rape, beat, bully, or pray the gay away. I call on the State of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines to repeal these archaic and draconian laws.
“I also encourage the state of St. Vincent and the Grenadines to create and enact legislation that expressly protects persons on grounds such as sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, and sex characteristics, including but not limited to comprehensive anti-discrimination laws.”
Barboo said that this will help to ensure that Vincentians, including LGBTQ+ persons, are better protected from harassment, discrimination, and violence, in all spheres of Vincentian society”.
ERAO SVG, founded in 2021, said it remains committed to promoting equality and non-discrimination in St. Vincent and the Grenadines.
In dismissing the case, Justice Henry said she recognises that all states do not have the same measure of resources to tackle the myriad of health and other issues confronting them.
“Without judgment, I take judicial notice of the notoriously known inadequacies of the current health care capabilities in the state amidst the increasing demands on it. I am satisfied that the policy issues which dictate the state’s response are matters best left to the state.”
The judge said that in all the circumstances and in light of her observations she had no doubt that the approach adopted by the state in relation to public health and public morality concerns on the issue “has a rational connection to the stated objective, and within the context of this state’s limited resources and the mores relied on, is most likely the least drastic means to achieve that goal”.
Justice Henry, therefore, made no finding that the challenged provisions infringe either sections 9 and10 of the Constitution. She further held that challenged provisions are not arbitrary, irrational, or contrary to the common law prohibition on irrational grounds.
She dismissed Johnson and MacLeish’s case respectively in their entirety and ordered them to pay costs of EC$7,500 (One EC dollar=US$0.37 cents) to the Office of the Attorney General.
CMC/k/ir/2024
