·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

High Court upholds deportation of Venezuelan nationals.

4 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Nov 15, CMC – A High Court judge has dismissed a motion by three Venezuelan women against their deportation after they were found to have illegally entered Trinidad and Tobago in 2019.

Justice Ricky Rahim in his 144-page ruling also dismissed the separate constitutional and judicial review claims by the women, saying that National Security Minister Fitzgerald Hinds did not act unfairly when issuing the deportation orders, despite each of the women having giving birth to children here.

The judge said the right to family life did not guarantee a right to choose the most suitable place to live, noting also that Hinds was responsible for safeguarding Trinidad and Tobago’s  borders and territorial sovereignty.

He said that the minister would also have taken into consideration the migrant crisis in Venezuela and the deleterious consequences for Trinidad and Tobago which had become easily accessible because of porous borders.

“He would have had to consider the increasing burden on the resources of the State as a consequence of the flight of Venezuelans by the thousands to Trinidad and Tobago and whether his actions may have been seen as an opening of a floodgate in which Venezuelan immigrants could obtain the right to stay and live in Trinidad and Tobago by giving birth to a child of a Trinidadian father while here.”

Justice Rahim said that Hinds duty went only so far as taking steps to inform himself of all the facts presented to him to ensure his decision was reasonable when ordering the women’s deportation.

“It must always be borne in mind when treating migrants that, as is the case with all human beings who find themselves in such an unenviable position, the main goal is to remain in Trinidad and Tobago. It means that the Immigration Division must be astute and careful to ensure that the information provided to them is accurate.”

The attorneys for the women had argued that the National Security Minister did not consider the women had given birth in 2021 and while admitting there was a lost opportunity to inform him of the situation, two of the women did not present evidence of their child’s birth to immigration officials, the judge said they suffered no unfairness as a result.

“In this case, the minister would have had to consider that the claimants of course had the option of leaving the children in the custody and care of their fathers. Fathers who, on their own evidence, are all stellar providers not only for the Trinidadian minors but also for the entire families brought to Trinidad.”

Justice Rahim said travel to Venezuela to visit their mothers was possible, as was communicating using technology, which happens “every day in Trinidad when parents are divorced with custody of the children being awarded to the father.”

“In the court’s view the best interest of the Trinidadian child with a Trinidadian father may have equally been that of the child staying with the father in Trinidad as opposed to being sent to Venezuela in what appear to be dire living circumstances set out by the very claimants in this case.”

Regarding the rights of the minors, The judge said there was no evidence their fathers would be any less caring if they remained here, or their mothers could take them to Venezuela and have their fathers visit them from time to time.

“The children in these cases are very young and resilient,” he said, adding that they would likely benefit from the unique exposure to two cultures to their benefit.

Justice Rahim also said from the evidence, the women were economic migrants and not refugees escaping persecution, nor were their children issued deportation orders.

“So whether the claimants take them to Venezuela will be a choice, presumably not only made by the claimants but with the involvement of the fathers in the decision-making process.

“Families exist in all types of permutations in the world of today. There is the linear family but there also exist families in which parents are separated with one parent residing within Trinidad and the other residing out of Trinidad,” the judge added.

The court heard that the women all had other children in Venezuela who also entered Trinidad and Tobago illegally.

In dismissing their claims, the judge ordered each woman to pay the State’s costs.

CMC/gj/ir/2023