PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, May 8, CMC – The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Roger Gaspard has sought to distance his office from the delay in the start of the murder case of several men accused of murdering former special state prosecutor, Dana Seetahal, in 2014.
Gaspard said since the conclusion of the preliminary enquiry, his office had made “numerous enquiries” about the delivery of the committal bundle but was repeatedly told the delay was due to its size.
In a statement, Gaspard said that in the absence of the relevant original documents from the Judiciary, not electronic copies as provided, his hands are tied.
“The consequence of not filing a valid indictment is that it would become liable to be quashed and no trial could occur. It should also be borne in mind that filing of an indictment by the DPP under section 25(3) of the IOPEA is not the inevitable consequence of a committal,” Gaspard said.
He said the DPP was required to consider the evidence in the bundle before determining the offences for which an indictment could be filed.
In an earlier statement, the Judiciary said that it had electronically forwarded the committed bundle comprising 8,100 pages to the DPP’s Office in three tranches, in December 2023 and January this year.
“For matters prior to Dec 2023, Section 25 of the Indictable Offences (Preliminary Enquiry) Act requires that committal bundles are transmitted to the DPP.
“Due to its size, the committal bundle in the case of The State vs Rajaee Ali and others, which contains over 8,100 pages, was sent to the Office of the DPP via file transfer protocol (FTP) in three parts on December 20, (2023) December 21, 2023, and January 5, 2024,” the Judiciary said in its statement.
But while he acknowledged receipt of the electronic bundle from the Judiciary, Gaspard said it was useless when it came to his office filing the indictment.
“Section 25(1) of the Indictable Offences (Preliminary Enquiry) Act (IOPEA) requires that the committal bundle be sent to me ‘without delay’ at the end of the preliminary enquiry.
“Under Section 25(2) of the IOPEA it is my statutory duty to keep the committal bundle until an indictment is filed in the High Court and then to transmit it to the Registrar of the Supreme Court.
“The committal bundle comprises the originals of the committal complaint, the deposition or statement of the witnesses, the documentary exhibits, the evidence on behalf of the accused persons, the warrants of commitment for trial and the recognisances of the witnesses,” he added.
Seetahal was killed on May 4, 2014, as she was driving home during the early hours from a night club. Her vehicle was blocked by two others and their occupants came out and shot her five times.
In 2015, several members of a mosque associated with the Jamaat-al-Muslimeen were arrested and charged with her murder. The charges against the 10 accused were laid on July 24, 2015 and the preliminary enquiry started on May 27, 2016.
It was concluded in July 2020 and the men Rajaee Ali, his brothers, Ishmael and Hamid Ali, Devaughn Cummings, Ricardo Stewart, Earl Richards, Stephan Cummings, Kevin Parkinson, Leston Gonzales, Roget Boucher and Gareth Wiseman were committed to stand trial for the crime.
Stephan Cummings was initially charged with the group but was made a State witness after he agreed to testify against his former friends and his brother.
In a statement marking the 10th anniversary of her death, Seetahal’s family noted “the lack of resolution” in her case “is not just a failure of our justice system; it is a betrayal of her legacy and an affront to the principles she stood for.
“The delay in bringing those accused of her murder to trial serves as a stark reminder of the impunity that persists in our society and the urgent need for accountability,” the family said, urging the authorities to redouble efforts to ensure her killers face the “full force of the law.
“We call for a swift and transparent trial to commence, providing the closure that her family and loved ones so rightfully deserve. Anything less would be an injustice not only to Dana Seetahal’s memory but to the ideals of justice and fairness that she championed throughout her life,” the statement said.
The family said that Seetahal was not only a prominent and respected person in the legal field but a beacon of integrity, who tirelessly advocated for justice and the rule of law.
“Her untimely demise sent shockwaves through the nation, shaking the very foundation of our legal system and sparking widespread outrage. Yet, despite a decade passing since her senseless murder, justice continues to elude us,” the family added.
CMC/af/ir/2024
