·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Judge displeased with attitude of prosecutors

3 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Mar 6, CMC – A High Court judge says he has asked the registrar to write to the Director of Public Prosecution (DPP), Roger Gaspard, regarding the conduct of the prosecution after two suspended police officers were acquitted of robbing a bakery owner in 2008.

“I have asked the registrar to write to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) to record the court’s displeasure at the conduct of the prosecutors, who walked out of the courtroom while the verdicts were being recorded. The court considers this highly disrespectful,” Justice Geoffrey Henderson told the court, adding he has left the matter for the DPP to “treat” the situation.

On Tuesday, a nine-member jury returned a mixed verdict in the case against acting corporal Nirmal Ramjattan, police constable Kipson Wynn. The law provides for a judge to accept a majority verdict in non-capital cases. The two men have been on suspension since their arrest in June 2008, when the charges were laid against them.

But the prosecutors Brandon Sookoo and Dylan Martin, left the court while the judge was still addressing the matter.

After thanking the jury for their service, Justice Henderson left the courtroom, but returned minutes later to put his displeasure on record.

Ramjattan, speaking on behalf of himself and his colleague, said that 16 years ago, they learned, as police officers, “what the system thought about you.

“Now 16 years later, all I would say is good always prevails over evil.”

Both men chose not to say whether they would return to the police service now that they have been cleared of the charges.

The state had argued that the two police officers, including Ramjattan, who headed the anti-crime unit,  had robbed Horace Seedansingh, the owner of the Golden Crown bakery in Tunapuna, east of here

Seedansingh, who returned to Trinidad to testify at the trial, said he got home during the early hours of April  6, 2008, after visiting a casino, when the two officers, whom he said he recognised at the police station when he went with his sister to make a report,  robbed him of TT$90,000 (One TT dollar=US$0.16 cents), his car and a lock. He also claimed they took his bank card and withdrew TT$5,000.

Seedansingh told the court, which staretd hearing the matter in january this year, that the assailants, dressed in black cargo pants, boots, jerseys and Marvin Gaye hats, hog-tied him and beat him before robbing him.

He also claimed one of the assailants threatened to kill him.

“I was confused. I was just crying,” he told the court.

But while Ramjattan testified at the trial, Wynn did not. He told the court that the first time he heard Seedansingh’s name was when he was detained by then-acting Sgt Jude Worrell, who also testified at the trial.

Their attorneys labelled Seedansingh a “liar” for the inconsistencies in his evidence, that of his sister who, in her 999 call to the police, described her brother’s assailants as “two African men,” and Seedansingh’s medical report, which said he had no physical injury when examined at the hospital on April 6, 2008, despite his claim that he was cuffed, kicked and got a “buss mouth.”

In their closing addresses, the attorneys reminded the jury that “not all police are bad”.

CMC/ag/ir/2024