·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Court dismisses COVID-19 related charge against Customs officer

4 min read

KINGSTOWN, St. Vincent, Oct 4, CMC – A magistrate court has dismissed a case against a Customs officer, who had held up a placard in the capital during a protest against the COVID-19 vaccine mandate which came into effect in December 2021.

Magistrate John Ballah, said that the prosecution had not provided any evidence to support the charge that Dave Crosby, 54, had organised, promoted, led, or addressed the January 14, 2022 protest, as the prosecution alleged.

Crosby was charged under section 10 of the Public Order Act, which gives a police officer the power to require anyone who is addressing or addressed a meeting taking place within 200 yards of certain premises, or who is or appears to the police officer to be an organiser or promoter of it, to disperse.

In his ruling  the magistrate said there were legal issues that the court felt were not addressed by either the prosecutor or defendant.

“The prosecution almost alluded to it. Those issues, I believe, are important to the matter. It is whether or not a protest falls under the Public Order Act. The Public Order Act clearly speaks to meetings and processions,” the magistrate said.

The magistrate said that from his research, processions are marches and in order to have a procession, notice must be given by the Commissioner of Police, but not to ask for permission.

“The notice must be given and the Commissioner would respond in writing as to whether or not the route is viable. If the Commissioner of Police says it is not a viable route, he will give an alternative route. If the procession fails to follow the alternative route given by the commissioner, they are in breach of the legislation.”

Magistrate Ballah said the legal issue is whether a group of people standing outside the Parliament constitutes a meeting.

“Nobody answered that. The court will not answer that,” Ballah said, noting that the defence had highlighted the lack of evidence that Crosby was a leader, coordinator or someone who addressed the meeting.

“The first hurdle is whether there was a meeting. Nobody addressed that. The next hurdle was whether he addressed the meeting,” the magistrate said, adding that the court did not think that Crosby holding and showing a placard amounted to him addressing a meeting.

He said that while in holding the placard Crosby was showing that he was protesting, it did not amount to an address.

“What is important is whether the prosecution led evidence that he was a leader. No such evidence was led.”

He said that the issue of where Crosby was properly arrested “was neither here nor there” said magistrate Ballah, who served two decades as a police officer before retiring and being appointed a magistrate. He said an arrest can be constructive.

“So if I am a police and I say to my clerk, ‘You are under arrest’ or ‘Come with me; let us go’ and I am taking her to the station and … she feels in her mind she is arrested because once she is at the station she does not move, because she thinks if I move, I am obviously resisting arrest, she is under arrest.”

Ballah said he therefore did not see as of great importance the issue of whether Crosby was arrested or detained.

“The defendant clearly realised that he was under arrested. He went with the police, he sat in the station, he  waited until the next day when corporal Patrick informed him of the office,” Ballah said, noting, however, ruled that the lack of measurement was an issue.

“While the man on the street can tell you the market is under 200 yards from the court house, the police should have taken some measurements,” he said, adding that if the police had taken measurements, it would have been clear or cogent.

He said that while Crosby gave that admission and the court accepted the admission, it would have been more prudent for the police to take the measurement.

Ballah said he could speak to the legislation clearly because of the number of lectures he has given on it.

“What would have been more appreciate to charge him under is section 12,” he said, adding that had the charge been brought under that section, there would have been no need to show that he was the leader or organiser.

“One only needed to show that he participated in the public meeting and there are cases that suggest that a protest falls within the ambit of a public meeting,” Ballah said.

“The most appropriate charge would have been section 12. In light of these deficiencies, I am not saying the police may have been wrong or right but in light of these deficiencies, the matter must be dismissed,” Ballah said.

The prosecution had argued that on January 14, 2022,  Parliament was in session and a police officer was dispatched to the area of the High Court building where protesters had gathered.

The officer went to the group of people who were directly in front of the gate at the time and spoke to them, but Crosby refused to move after being asked to do so on more than one occasion.  He was later arrested and charged.

CMC/kc/ir/2023