KINGSTOWN, St. Vincent, Nov 1, CMC -The High Court has dismissed the case brought by a lawyer and an opposition legislator seeking to review the decision by the government to bar lawyers and restrict legislators parking in the courthouse yard as they had been doing for decades.
Justice Birnie Stephenson in dismissing the case brought by attorney Jemalie John and opposition senator Shevern Lewis-John, also denied permission to file for judicial review of the government’s decision.
“.The claimants have failed to establish that they have a good an arguable case with a reasonable prospect of success as is required.
“It is therefore not necessary to proceed to consider the substantive application for judicial review which in reality is not likely to succeed. This court makes no order as to costs,” Justice Stephenson said in her ruling.
The claimants had asked the High Court to declare that the Cabinet’s decision to prohibit lawyers who do not work for the government from using the Courthouse yard and restrict its use by legislators without providing them an opportunity to be heard was procedurally in breach of the principles of natural justice.
They were also seeking a declaration that the private lawyers and legislators had a legitimate expectation to be heard if the decision to prohibit or restrict their use of the courthouse yard for parking was contemplated.
They were further seeking a declaration that the Cabinet’s decision to restrict parking in the Courthouse yard without granting lawyers and MPs an opportunity to be heard was violative of their legitimate expectation and unlawful.
But in her ruling, the judge said “this court asks the question, “was there a clear unambiguous unequivocal promise made to the claimants to allow the to park in the Courtyard?
“Was there detrimental reliance on any promise made by the claimants in the case at bar or a case made out by them in their evidence showing both a reliance and detriment?”
Justice Stephenson said that where there is a substantive legitimate expectation, it is expected that an authority makes a lawful representation that an individual will receive or continue to receive some kind of substantive benefit.
“Based on the facts adduced in the application before the court this most certainly does not arise and there is no likelihood that the claimant can pursue this arm or even have a chance of succeeding on such a claim,” she ruled.
She said that the way in which the Cabinet decided to deny parking in the Courtyard, without any prior consultation with the claimants, cannot be characterised as being so unfair as to amount to an abuse of power on the part of the Cabinet.
“However, pressing the inconvenience may be, there was no overriding public interest which had precluded any consultation or justified the lack of any consultation,” the judge said,
“It is in this court’s respectful view wholly unreasonable for Cabinet to be expected to seek out the views or give a hearing to persons who utilise the court yard for parking regarding their proposed decision…”
CMC/kc/ir/2023
