CASTRIES, St. Lucia, Feb 28, CMC – As the Government heads to Parliament Tuesday to amend the constitution to replace the Privy Council with the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) as St. Lucia’s final appeals court, Opposition Leader Allen Chastanet has accused the administration of rushing the process.
In a statement issued on Monday, a day after his United Workers Party (UWP) staged a protest, he insisted there should be no CCJ move without a referendum.
“This is hastily being done by the Government without sufficient consultation with the general public or dissemination of information on the pros and cons of this move. How many of you can confidently say that you know or understand how this move will impact you?” Chastanet asked citizens.
Noting that the governments of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Grenada and Antigua and Barbuda all held referendums on the issue – with citizens voting against the move in all three cases – the former prime minister said putting the matter to a public vote was appropriate for several reasons.
Chief among them, he said, is that it would ensure that the decision is made democratically and transparently.
“While it is ultimately up to the government to decide whether to adopt the CCJ as the final court of appeal, this decision should not be made without the input and consent of the people. A referendum would allow for a public debate on the issue, with both sides of the argument being heard and considered,” Chastanet said.
“A referendum would help to increase public awareness and understanding of the issue. Many people in St. Lucia may not be fully aware of what the CCJ is and how it works. By holding a referendum, the government can ensure that the public is fully informed about the issue before making a decision.
“Finally, a referendum would help to ensure that the decision is seen as legitimate and binding. If the government were to make the decision without consulting the people, there would always be a question of whether the decision was truly representative of the will of the people,” he added.
Chastanet urged residents to contact their Members of Parliament and “tell them no referendum, no CCJ!”
Of the 15 Caribbean Community (CARICOM) countries that signed on to the original jurisdiction of the Trinidad-based CCJ which was established in 2001, only four have made the transition to having it as their final appellate court – Barbados, Belize, Dominica and Guyana.
CMC/ed/2023
