·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

DPP provides update on various police related shootings

5 min read

CASTRIES, St. Lucia, Jun 19, CMC – The Director of Public Prosecution (DPP), Daarsrean Greene, Wednesday said that the investigations into the deaths of several people by police on May 5, 2011 “is near completion” and that the officers involved should be interviewed on suspicion “of reckless  manslaughter”.

The families of the five men had disputed the reports by the police that they were killed as a result of an intercepted robbery.

Greene, who was speaking at a news conference updating the country on a number of police-related killings dating back to several years, said “ further lines of enquiry have been explored” regarding the deaths of Kevin Ferdinand, Rosarius Marquis, John Baptiste Macfarlane, Mitchell Cadette and Allen Louisy, who were all shot and killed by police on May 5, 2011, at Vieux Fort, south of here.

“I find that this investigation is near completion and the evidence emanating from the investigation in the further lines of enquiry as aforesaid, is sufficient in my view to warrant the arrest and formal interviewing of the officers involved on suspicion of reckless manslaughter. I have advised the Commissioner accordingly,” he added.

Human Rights attorney and advocate, Mary Francis, who was present during the news conference, has consistently called for justice.

Prior to the news conference, Francis, who is also the executive director of the National Centre for Legal Aid and Human Rights, said she had reliable information that the police hierarchy had ignored the DPP’s advice that there was a case to answer.

The fatal police shooting of the men, who had been dubbed the “Vieux Fort Five,” was among a wave of killings that occurred between 2010 and 2011 as part of Operation Restore Confidence (ORC) as police responded to a violent crime wave in the country.

Greene also provided an update on other cases, including that of Reginald Jean, who was shot and killed by police on February 28, 2011, at Marchand on the outskirts of the capital.

“I have advised the Commissioner of Police that the further lines of inquiry… embarked upon by the investigating team which was done subsequent to the coroner’s inquest in this matter have revealed sufficient evidence, in my view, to warrant the arrest and formal interviewing of the officers involved on suspicion of reckless manslaughter.

“I have therefore requested the Commissioner of Police, that the investigative team be directed to complete the investigation, thus allowing due process of law to function.”

Regarding the death of Dwight Henry, who was shot and killed by police on April 12, 2011 in Anse La Raye, west of here,  the DPP said that having reviewed the matter in its entirety, including the further lines of enquiry explored by the investigative team, “I do not find that there exists sufficient evidence to warrant the arrest of the officers involved”.

But regarding the death of Arnold Joseph, who was shot and killed by police on May 22, 2019. Greene said “this matter has not been formally sent to my Office for advice, contrary to what has been said in the media.

“My Office remains committed to providing advice as soon as we are in receipt of it in this matter once the request is made by the Commissioner of Police,” he told reporters.

Greene also commented on the death of Chakadan Daniel, who was found dead whilst in custody at the Micoud Police Station on October 23, 2013.

He said the investigative team is also charged with the review and continued investigations into this matter.

“I can assure you that this matter remains active in terms of investigations as there are outstanding lines of enquiry to be explored, which includes forensic testing in relation to exhibits recovered in this matter.

“These exhibits to date, from my understanding, have not been submitted for testing. Therefore based on the evidence reviewed thus far, I find that the investigation of Chakadan Daniel is incomplete and as such I urge the Commissioner of Police to cause these outstanding matters in the course of the investigation to be addressed.”

In addressing the situation regarding the death of Kimberly De Leon, the wife of a police officer, who was shot and killed at her residence at the Morne, just outside the capital on October 29,  2018. The accountant who had been employed in the public service, was shot several times.

The authorities have given no motive for the killing and Greene said, “this matter, I can assure the public, remains an active investigation and this investigation is being conducted by the Major Crimes Unit of the Royal St. Lucia Police Force.

“I am aware that there are outstanding lines of enquiry in this matter which require the assistance of external agencies. I am in receipt of a preliminary file and I can conclude, based on this preliminary file, that this matter needs to be completed in terms of its investigation,” he said, urging the police commissioner to do what is necessary to ensure that these lines of enquiry are carried out so that he can be updated and subsequently be able to provide an update to the public in due course.

Greene said the death of Oliver Gobat, 38, a luxury hotel owner, on April 24, 2014, has continued to attract significant public interest. His body was found in his burnt-out Range Rover vehicle in a remote area at Cap Estate, Gros Islet, north of here.. According to police, he was badly beaten and shot twice in the head.

Gobat, known as Ollie, was born on the island but grew up in Surrey, England, and he and his two older brothers ran a five-star boutique hotel at an exclusive resort in St Lucia. Following an inquest, the British Foreign Office said it had been agreed in principle UK police could assist investigators in St Lucia.

Greene told reporters Wednesday that “the investigation has been assigned to the investigative team and I have been reviewing this evidence for the last seven years.

“This matter has proved to be very complex in nature and further lines of enquiry are being pursued with the assistance of external agencies. I remain confident, based on my review of this matter, that all possible lines of enquiry are being explored to bring resolution to this matter.”

CMC/af/ir/2024