·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Church outlines position regarding HPV vaccines

3 min read

BELMOPAN, Belize, May 15, CMC – The Catholic Diocese of Belize City and Belmopan says while it affirms the value of the HPV vaccine, it does not however consider “a standardised school based vaccination model to  be the most appropriate approach for a sexually transmitted infection.

“The Church’s concerns are not about the vaccine itself, but about proportionality, parents rights, informed consent and the sensitive moral context surrounding a sexually transmitted infection,”  it said in a statement.

Health authorities, including the he Belize Cancer Society, say the vaccine could play a significant role in the prevention of cervical  cancer and that the science is clear: girls who miss the HPV vaccine face a much higher chance of developing cervical cancer later in life with devastating consequences.

“Women that get cervical cancer advanced stage, the… family have to invest between forty to fifty thousand Belize dollars (One Belie dollar=US$0.49 cents) to receive treatment at that stage, and maybe they’re not even able to save the woman life after that great investment,” said Dr. Natalia Beer, Technical Advisor, in the Minister of Health & Wellness.

She said that an at an oncology clinic held in April, 19 women with cervical cancer were seen, evaluated by a specialist, and a few of them got surgery.

“And out of these 19  women that had cervical cancer, only one was in age of receiving the HPV vaccine when we look at the year of introduction of the vaccine, but she was not vaccinated.

“And then the other 18, they were not age-eligible for the vaccine based on the year of introduction.,”  Dr. Beer said, adding “I can put myself and compare to a young girl that got the vaccine this year earlier.

“Who have greater risk to get cervical cancer? Me. And why? Because I did not get HPV vaccine. And that girl, she will be protected from HPV vaccine in the case and especially if they get the vaccine before exposing themselves to the virus. So yes, low vaccination coverage is equal to higher incidence of morbidity and mortality due to cervical cancer, a vaccine-preventable cancer.”

But the Catholic Church “insists on the rights of parents to  genuine informed consent, which includes adequate disclosure of benefits, risks and alternatives, a true understanding of the medical information provided, and voluntariness from free pressure and coercion.

“Decision regarding HPV vaccination are best made within the clinical setting, where parents – who possess rights and responsibilities for the care of  their children-  can exercise informed consent in collaboration with trusted medical professionals in  accord with their moral and cultural values”.

The  Church said the doctor-patient relationship allows families to ask questions, receive indiviualised medical guidance and “make decisions based on on the specific needs and circumstances of their child.

“ A standardised school-based model can unintentionally weaken this essential process by applying the same procedural approach to all medical interventions an circumstances, even though not all  medical decisions require the same degree of personnel, ethical, developmental and familial discernment”.

The Church also  noted that while the vaccine being provided now  “offers strong protect against several major HPV strains, it does not cover every cancer causing strain present in our region”.

The statement said that grounded in the social  teaching of the Church, it remains committed to working with the Ministry of Health “in a spirit of mutual collaboration, with the shared goal of upholding the integral dignity and authentic well-being of every child”.

CMC/aj/ir/2026