·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Judge hands down five life sentences to convicted murderer

3 min read

KINGSTON, Jamaica, Oct 21, CMC – A High Court judge has sentenced convicted murderer Rushane Barnett to five life sentences after indicating that “this is a crime for which adjectives and descriptions were insufficient and which shocked and horrified a nation, even in this country which has unfortunately gotten too used to murder”.

Justice Leighton Pusey made the comments Thursday as he handed down the sentencing in the case in which Barnett was convicted of killing 31-year-old Kimesha Wright and her children 15-year-old Kimanda Smith, 11-year-old Shara-Lee Smith, five-year-old Rafaella Smith, and 23-month-old Kishawn Henry.

The judge told the Court Wright should be celebrated for her ambitious nature and generosity of spirit and not blamed for unwittingly opening her home and heart to her cousin who eventually killed and her children.

Justice Pusey, who acknowledged that he was struggling for adjectives to describe the “direct viciousness” of Barnett said “what we need to remember in this matter is the lives of the persons who lost their lives, and I have deliberately been mentioning their names continuously.

“I have also been deliberate in not mentioning the name of the accused man because it is my eternal hope that we will forget his name, although it seems as if his name has [gone] wide and abroad…

“In the same way as other persons who have committed similar offences, they’ve become a footnote and are only remembered when we look for legal precedence. I would hope that we remember these persons. Miss Wright, in particular, was significant as a young woman who was looking after her four children and also studying and finding time to run a shop,” he said.

Justice Pusey said that the three eldest children “would have been in school and had their own hopes and dreams and the possibility of them joining their father overseas,” adding that the father will not have the opportunity of seeing his smallest child, Kishawn going to school.

“I think it’s important also to remember, for Miss Wright, that she was somebody who, despite the difficulties she had, she was still able to be generous enough to try to help somebody who was in need. And I think it was important enough for us to celebrate that generosity, and don’t think of it as something which opened her to the situation that happened. In other words, it was not her fault, it was others who were responsible,” Justice Pusey said solemnly.

The judge said he deliberately avoided mentioning the injuries sustained by the five people, during the pre-dawn attack at their house in Cocoa Piece, Clarendon, on June 21 this year.

He said both the Crown and the defence had proposed life sentences for Barnett, given that the death penalty had been taken off the table, as Barnett had pleaded guilty.

Justice Pusey said the major issue to be decided by the court had been the relevant time the convict would serve before being eligible to be considered for parole, noting however that parole was “by no means automatic.

“Eligibility for parole means that at the expiration of the time the person may apply for parole, and if they are deemed sufficiently suitable, they may have supervised release from custody. The parole board will look at several factors, including the prisoner’s behaviour in custody, the nature of the offence, and whether he is still a threat, and the presence of a suitable place to go,” the judge noted.

 

“A person on parole is always under supervision and can be recalled at any time. In short, eligibility for parole does not mean an automatic release from custody. The most a prisoner can hope for is supervised release under stringent conditions,” he added.

The judge said that the crimes fell under “the most serious category” recognised in law.

CMC/gf/ir/2022