GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Sept 6, CMC – Vice President Bharrat Jagdeo is seeking leave to appeal to the Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) after the Court of Appeal earlier this week rejected his appeal against a default judgement ordering him to pay GUY$20 million (One Guyana dollar=US$0.004 cents) to former government minister, Annette Ferguson, whom he had defamed in 2019.
Jagdeo wants the CCJ, Guyana’s highest court, to have the libel case reopened or struck out altogether.
“The grant of special leave is appropriate since the matters in controversy concern a point of law of public importance, the learned judges of the Court of Appeal making an egregious error of law, the Applicant/Intended Appellant having a real prospect of success, and there being a substantial injustice to the Applicant if the decision of the Court of Appeal is not reversed,” Jagdeo said in his application for leave to appeal to the CCJ.
The High Court had issued a default judgement on March 11, 2023 against Jagdeo because he had failed to defend himself in the lawsuit that stemmed from statements he made in the media in December 2019 about Ferguson’s acquisition of land and construction of her house.
Ferguson maintained the statements were slanderous, untrue and caused irreparable damage to her character and reputation.
The former minister said in court papers that the statements and publications suggested that she acquired unexplained wealth by dishonest means. Ferguson had called on Jagdeo and Guyana Times to provide evidence to the court to support their claims.
The Court of Appeal this week dismissed a notice for special leave filed by Jagdeo to challenge the Full Court’s decision which upheld the High Court ruling that Ferguson, be awarded a default judgment.
Further, the Court of Appeal has ordered that the matter be remitted to Justice Sandra Kurtzious to award damages for libel.
Jagdeo had through a series of applications sought to challenge Justice Kurtzious ruling tin favour of Ferguson, who had filed the lawsuit against him and the Guyana Times newspaper, while he was opposition leader and she was a government minister.
Justice Kurtzious made the orders of judgement after it was found that Jagdeo failed to file a defence within the required time provided for under the Civil procedure rules of the Supreme Court.
Jagdeo’s application to the Court of Appeal followed a decision by Chief Justice Roxane George and Justice Priya Sewnarine-Beharry who in the Full Court were unable to reach a unanimous decision on the case resulting in the original judgment against Jagdeo being upheld.
Among other things, Jagdeo through his attorney, Devindra Kissoon, was seeking to appeal the Court’s refusal to consider and grant an application to have the matter remitted to new sh judges in the Full Court.
In his application seeking to go before the CCJ, Jagdeo wants the Trinidad-based court to suspend Justice Kurtzious’ award of damages and costs until it hears his appeal.
Jagdeo is also asking the CCJ to set aside the default judgement and send back the case to the High Court. Alternatively, he hopes that the CCJ can hear his appeal of the Full Court’s decision since the Court of Appeal on Monday ruled that a divided Full Court has not made a decision and that it had no jurisdiction to hear an appeal from that court.
“The Learned Judges of the Court of Appeal erred in law by failing to find that the legal effect of a divided Full Court is appealable,” Jagdeo said in application, adding that the Court of Appeal erred in law by finding that the applicant acted prematurely by appealing the default judgement, failing to overturn the Full Court’s refusal to either recall its divided judgement and remit the case to three fresh Full Court judges.
He is also arguing that the Appeal Court failed to grant an extension of time to file a fresh appeal if no decision had in fact been rendered by the Full Court, failing to avert the miscarriage of justice which inevitably flows from its decision, the applicant being without any remedy despite having a defence to the underlying claim, and failing to grant the applicant leave to appeal.
In his affidavit in support of his application, Jagdeo said his then lawyer and legal adviser to the People’s Progressive Party (PPP), Anil Nandlall, had been so busy with court cases before and after the March 2, 2020 general elections, political duties and the court itself had been closed for COVID, all resulting in the inadvertent failure to file a defence on or around February 25, 2020.
“I made several inquiries about the filing of a defence, and at all times was under the mistaken impression that the matter had been attended to. I had no reason to believe otherwise, and had I known that the defence was not filed, I would have immediately taken steps to ensure that the proper application was made to the Court,” agdeo said.
Jagdeo said that Nandlall, now the country’s Attorney General, failure to file the defence was not due to neglect “but rather a combination of unusual and exceptional time sensitive circumstances relating to Guyana’s election, which caused counsel to fail to comply with the time limits established by the rules.”
He said unknowing to him or his lawyer, Ferguson on February 24, 2021 filed for a default judgment which was granted by Justice Kurtzious, awarding GY$20 million in damages and GUY$75,000 in costs.
He said that was done, without conducting an assessment hearing, “depriving me on an opportunity to be heard at least as to damages.”
Jagdeo is blaming the High Court for breaching the civil procedure rules by failing to notify his lawyer of an impending default judgement so that the defence could have been filed, and cited Ms Ferguson for not notifying the High Court of an interlocutory case.
“Separately, I have been informed by counsel and verily believe that I have a constitutional right to be notified of an application for a default judgment, which was not done. I believe it to be simply unfair that an applicant can secretly apply for a default judgment without
notification,” Jagdeo said.
CMC/gt/ir/2023
