GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Nov 7, CMC – The Jamaica Bar Association (JBA) has joined its Guyana counterpart in condemning the arrest of a lawyer here, who last Friday asked the High Court to declare as unconstitutional the arrest and detention by police of any lawyer for advising a client to remain silent during questioning.
The Guyana Bar Association (GBA), Guyana Association of Women Lawyers, the Organization of Commonwealth Caribbean Bar Associations (OCCBA) and the Commonwealth Lawyers Association (CLA) have all condemned the arrest.
In a statement, the JBA said it regards the arrest and detention of Tamieka Clarke as “an attack on a fundamental principle of the rule of law.
“We condemn this action and are very concerned about this assault on the legal profession It is a clear departure from the Constitution of Guyana which enshrines the right to silence in the course of criminal investigation consistent with the advice of counsel in the matter. This gross encroachment by the State has the result or undermining the rule of law and we shall remain carefully attentive in this cause,” the Jamaica Bar Association added.
Clarke last Friday moved to the High Court after she was arrested on October 28, by members of the Guyana Police Force’s Special Organised Crime Unit (SOCU) for informing her client, who has been accused of computer-related fraud, to remain silent.
She has since sued the Guyana Police Force (GPF) for more than GUY$300,000 (One Guyana dollar=US$0.004 cents) for her wrongful arrest and detention by police and the temporary seizure of her mobile phone without justification.
Clarke wants the High Court to declare that her fundamental right to personal liberty as guaranteed and protected by Article 139 of Guyana’s Constitution was breached by SOCU officers when she was arrested and detained for advising her client to remain silent.
Further, she is asking the High Court to declare that her fundamental right and freedom against arbitrary arrest as set out and provided for in Article 40 of Guyana’s Constitution was breached and/or violated by police officers when they arrested and detained her at SOCU’s headquarters and that the detention and seizure of her cellular phone by SOCU officers without her permission and without lawful excuse was wrongful.
Clarke is seeking a High Court declaration that any lawyer practicing in Guyana is entitled to advise a client of the Client’s entitlement to remain silent when being questioned by members of any law enforcement agency or body in Guyana; is entitled to consult with his/her client in private without the contents of the said consultation being recorded in any way including by means of audio visual recording by any law enforcement agency in Guyana or elsewhere, and is entitled to advise any person who has sought her counsel to exercise the right to remain silent when questioned by a member of any law enforcement agency in Guyana
In her case brought against the Attorney General, Clarke wants the High Court to declare the entitlement to the fundamental right and freedoms as set out in Article 40 of Guyana’s Constitution includes the right of any citizen to remain silent when questioned by an officer of a law enforcement agency in Guyana; the fundamental rights and freedoms as set out in Article 40 of the Constitution includes the right of access of all arrested, detained or imprisoned persons to be provided with adequate opportunities, time and facilities to be visited by and to communicate and consult with an Attorney at law, without delay, interception or censorship and in full confidentiality.
Clarke is seeking damages of more than GUY$100,000 each for wrongful arrest and detention, false imprisonment by SOCU agents, breach of her fundamental rights and freedoms as set out in Article 40 of Guyana’s Constitution and exemplary damages for the threat of the arrest on October 25 and for the arrest on October 28 for attempting to pervert the course of justice on the basis of the advice rendered in her capacity as lawyer admitted to practice in Guyana, to her client to remain silent when questioned by an officer of the GPF.
Meanwhile, Attorney General Anil Nandlall has rejected suggestions that the action against the lawyer was being condoned and authorised by a State or government agency.
“Let me state unequivocally that that absolutely is not true. There is no policy of our government that will ever be subversive to the rule of law or the constitution or the constitutional rights of Guyanese,” he told the government’s Department of Public Information.
CMC/gt/ir/2022
