GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Jan 17, CMC – A High Court judge, noting that Court could not intervene in the work of the Parliament, Monday dismissed a motion by eight opposition legislators who sought to overturn their suspension for their role in an unrest at the legislative chambers in December 2021.
The fracas in the National Assembly occurred while Finance Minister Dr Ashni Singh was outlining the benefits of the new Natural Resources Fund legislation.
In her ruling, Justice Damon Younge said the Court not intervene in the work of the Parliament as the Standing Orders are not subjected to the provisions of the Guyana Constitution.
The judge also ordered that the eight legislators – Opposition Chief Whip Christopher Jones, Sherod Duncan, Natasha Singh-Lewis, Ganesh Mahipaul, Annette Ferguson, Vinceroy Jordan, Tabitha Sarabo-Halley and Maureen Philadelphia – have until February 6 to meet the GUY$350,000 (One Guyana dollar=US$0.004 cents) costs to the defendants – House Speaker Manzoor Nadir, Clerk of the National Assembly Sherlock Isaacs and Attorney General Anil Nandlall.
In her ruling the judge said the National Assembly’s Standing Orders are only subjected to the Constitution if there are regulations and that the Parliament must be able to conduct its affairs without interference from the Court.
She said when it comes to the internal operations of the National Assembly, only that organ could exclusively control the management of its own internal affairs, not the judiciary.
Justice Younge said matters of the Privilege Committees are only controlled by the National Assembly, and that legislators have taken an oath to be bound by the rules of the National Assembly. She said the court would not inquire into the internal affairs of the National Assembly otherwise it would amount to a usurpation of the powers of the Parliament.
The eight opposition legislators had argued that they were not given a right to a hearing by the bipartisan Privileges Committee which recommended that they be suspended for their part in the incident on December 29, 2021.
Based on the report of the Privileges Committee, Jones, Duncan, Singh-Lewis, Mahipaul and Philadelphia were suspended from four consecutive sittings for conducting themselves in a gross disorderly, contumacious, and disrespectful manner, and repeatedly ignoring the authority of the Assembly and that of the Speaker, and thereby committing contempt and breaches of privileges.
Ferguson and Jordan were suspended for six consecutive sittings for committing serious violations which were severe and egregious by unauthorizedly removing the Parliamentary Mace from its rightful position in a disorderly fashion, causing damage to the Mace, injuring and assaulting a staff of the Parliament Office, while attempting to remove the Mace from the Chamber.
Parliamentarian Tabitha Sarabo-Halley was suspended for six consecutive sittings for unauthorizedly entering the communication control room of the Arthur Chung Conference Centre and destroying several pieces of audio-visual equipment, being public property.
In their court motion, the eight legislators had called on the High Court to declare that the Report of the Parliamentary Sessional Select Committee of Privileges is unconstitutional and breaches the principles of Natural Justice. They argued that they were not afforded an opportunity to be heard by the Privileges Committee as guaranteed by Guyana’s Constitution.
The High Court was also been asked to issue an order to all the eight opposition parliamentarians to perform their duties as Members of the National Assembly until they had been afforded the right to be heard.
CMC/gt/ir/2023
