·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

CCJ awards full pension benefits to former chief executive officer

2 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Mar 20, CMC – The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has awarded full pension benefits to Maurice Arjoon, the former chief executive officer of the Guyana-based New Building Society Ltd, (NBS) reversing the decision of Court of Appeal in that country.

The ruling on Tuesday was the first time in which the CCJ integrated a sign language interpreter into its judgment delivery process.

The CCJ heard that on August 14, 2007, Arjoon was dismissed by the  NBS after being employed there for 30 years.

Arjoon, who was due to retire six months later at age 60.  was also dismissed as a company director/secretary “for what the company alleged was ‘serious misconduct’.

Arjoon had made pension contributions over the years, and so did NBS on his behalf. He initiated proceedings in the High Court, asserting that he had been wrongfully dismissed.

The trial judge, Justice Reynolds, upheld the claim, and found that Arjoon had been wrongfully and unlawfully dismissed and awarded Arjoon a payment in lieu of notice, severance benefits, and a lump sum representing full pension benefits up to 30 June 2017, and thereafter a monthly pension until his death.

The Court of Appeal agreed with the trial judge’s finding that Arjoon had been wrongfully dismissed, but reversed the trial judge’s award of full pension benefits, and instead awarded him a sum representing the pooled pension contributions of both Arjoon and NBS over the years.

Arjoon appealed to the CCJ and the respondents cross-appealed.

The appeal and cross-appeal were heard on October, 10 last year and on October 23, the CCJ made an order setting aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal and restoring the order of Justice Reynolds.

However, the issue of Arjoon’s entitlement to severance pay until the CCJ issued its reasons for decision.

In its reasons, the CCJ agreed that Arjoon had been wrongfully dismissed, and that he was entitled to full pension benefits as ordered by Justice Reynolds. On the issue of Arjoon’s claim to severance payment under the Termination of Employment and Severance Pay Act (TESPA), the Court was divided 3-2.

Justice Denys Barrow, writing for the majority which included President Adrian Saunders and Justice Peter Jamadar, explained that it could be considered that Arjoon involuntarily retired and was therefore entitled to receive his full pension benefits.

As to Arjoon’s claim to severance pay in addition to pension, however, Justice Barrow underscored that since full pension benefits were to be paid to Arjoon as if he had retired, the argument that severance pay should be paid because Arjoon was terminated and was thus unable to retire, could not succeed. In separate concurring opinions.

But Justices Maureen Rajnauth-Lee and Andrew Burgess concurred with the majority except on the decision refusing severance pay to Arjoon. They were of the view that having regard to the policy behind TESPA, Mr Arjoon was entitled to both his full pension benefits and severance pay.

CMC/gt/ir/2024