GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Sept 6, CMC – The Commission of Inquiry (COI) set up to examine the circumstances that led to the deadly fire at a secondary school in May, has rejected a request from the lawyer representing the school child charged with causing the blaze, for the proceedings to be halted until the court case has ended.
The 15-year-old school girl, who is being held at the Juvenile Holding Centre, is accused of setting fire to the dormitory resulting in the deaths of 19 fellow students between the ages of 12 to 17 and a five-year-old boy.
She was not required to enter a plea.
Her attorney, Dexter Todd, who last month had called for the charges against her to be dropped, last week wrote to the Director of Public Prosecution (DPP), asking for the proceedings of the imminent COI to be stayed until all criminal proceedings against his client, is complete.
The young girl has been on remand since May 2023 with full disclosure in the matter completed on July 20. Tendering of statements, and cross examination of witnesses, were set to begin last Friday, but Todd worries that pretrial publicity from the COI can serve as a danger to the criminal proceedings against his client.
“After this Commission of Inquiry is completed, it is reasonable to conclude that our client will not have an untainted or impartial jury since a lot of the evidence likely to be exposed by the COI will also be ventilated at the preliminary inquiry/trial,” he wrote in the August 31letter to the DPP.
However, secretary to the Commission, Japhet Shadiq, speaking on News Source television news programme here on Tuesday night, said that the Commission would be proceeding with its work and that safeguards will be put in place to protect the rights of the children.
“Yes, the Commission will be proceeding with its work,” he said, adding that the COI will be guided by the Commission of Inquiry Act, in particular section 9 which allows it to create its own rules and operate in a manner it deems fit.
Shadiq said given the sensitive nature of the case, some of the hearings will be held in camera and would not therefore be streamed live.
“The Terms of Reference, as you know, have different parts and it requires us to investigate….so the Commission will be proceeding and depending on which aspect we are looking at we will make the necessary arrangements for the hearings to be held.
“Where it concerns sensitive parts, especially children and so on, then the Commission will make different arrangements…but yes we will be proceeding,” he told television viewers.
The secretary to the Commission did not share Todd’s view that his client could be facing a tainted jury, indicating that the COI is different from the court case.
“In terms of what we are going to do to guard against prejudice or an impact on that trial. I can say that all the information and every thing that will be taken by the Commission in the sensitive areas, those information will be strictly guarded,” he said, adding “ a lot of safe guard will be in place”.”
In his letter to the DPP, which was dated August 31 but made available to the media on September 2, Todd wrote” we trust that in the interest of fairness that the Commission will allow good sense to prevail and accede to our request,” the letter added.
CMC/gt/nhb/2023
