BELMOPAN, Belize, Oct 20, CMC – The prosecution has hinted at the possibility of filing an appeal after a Magistrate’s Court found former police corporal, Elmer Nah not guilty of possession of a cache of firearms, ammunition and bulletproof vests.
Nah, along with his common-law-wife, Epifania Caliz, and her brother, former police constable Manuel Caliz, had been intercepted on November 6, 2021 in a vehicle on the Southern Highway.
Nah’s interception came on the night of a drug plane landing on the Southern Highway near Bladen Village. In connection with that incident, several persons, including Nah and four other police officers, were charged for facilitating the landing of the plane.
But Senior Magistrate Baja Shoman found that Nah and his co-defendants were not guilty of the charges. In the case of the Caliz siblings, they had no knowledge of the guns and vests and were mere occupants of the vehicle, while the court determined that Nah was returning the items to another officer, Corporal Richard Arnold who had previously signed the weapons out and left them in the vehicle which Nah was driving that particular night.
The prosecutor, Alifa Elrington, who is also head of the Prosecution Branch, told reporters that the court, having found that Nah got called to report to duty still, in my opinion, does not come under Section 33, which would then have allowed him to be in possession of ammunition that was not assigned to him by virtue the Belize Police Department or by virtue of law. Section 33 is specific that you are in possession of a firearm if you’re going to be doing your duty.
“At that point, that he had initially been in possession of a firearm and the evidence that came out that he, when he found out that he was in possession of a firearm, he was not on duty and he was not on duty with firearm or ammunition that was assigned to him, separate and apart from a nine millimeter firearm that he was not charged for under the circumstances,” she added.
But Nah’s attorney, Dickie Bradley, said “we are not at all surprised that a court of law, once again in our country, has shown that you can get justice.
“The police were wrong from the get-go to charge all three persons and have them subjected to what they were subjected to. You all know that when they charge you for ammunition and firearms, you automatically go to jail.
“The time has come for that law to be amended. If the police make you sign out for the gun or no sign out, that is an internal matter. We’re talking about a criminal charge that will land you in jail for a minimum of five years. There are two different things. I’m sorry that they don’t pick that up. I’m sorry they don’t pick that up. How many innocent people are facing charges when there is no crime that has been committed, Bradley added.
Elrington said that as far as she is concerned the way that the Firearms Act is written, “the court it is required that the Crown proves that you are in possession.
“Hence the reason we see so many people arrested and at some point in time, in relation to guns found and ammunition found in homes and we go through the process. I don’t believe that I have to prove knowledge.
“The way the legislation is written, the evidential burden switches over to the defense and the defense must prove or must give a lawful excuse for being in possession of a firearm,” she said, adding she is considering appealing Thursday’s ruling.
CMC/af/ir/2023
CMC/af/ir/2023
