BRIDGETOWN, Barbados, Oct 17, CMC – The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has reserved its judgement in the extradition matter involving former insurance executive Alex Tasker, who is wanted in the United States on money laundering and conspiracy to launder money charges.
The Trinidad-based CCJ, which is also Barbados’ highest and final court, met here on Monday to hear the matter and heard from lawyers for Tasker and the US government on the matter.
It ruled that it would reserve its decision so as “to hear further interventions” from the applicant.
In July, the CCJ had rejected Tasker’s application for special leave to challenge the decision of the Court of Appeal, saying it did not meet the necessary requirements. The Appeal Court had dismissed his attempt to appeal the order made in September 2021 by Chief Magistrate Ian Weekes for him to surrender to US authorities.
In September 2021, Weekes ruled that Tasker, a former executive with the Insurance Corporation of Barbados Ltd. (ICBL) who is linked to the Donville Inniss cash-for-coverage scandal, be turned over to United States authorities to stand trial.
In April 2021, Innis, a former minister of industry and an elected member of Parliament of Barbados was sentenced to two years in prison for his role in a scheme to launder bribe payments from the Barbados-based insurance company through bank accounts in New York.
Inniss, a US permanent resident who resided in Tampa, Florida, and Barbados, was convicted by a federal jury of two counts of money laundering and one count of conspiracy to commit money laundering on January 16, 2020.
According to the evidence presented at trial, in 2015 and 2016, Inniss took part in a scheme to launder into the United States approximately US$36,000 in bribes that he had received from high-level executives of the ICBL.
Chief Magistrate Ian Weekes in granting Tasker’s extradition said ‘the entire series of transactions as submitted before me in the bundle and the other information satisfies this court that Mr Alex Tasker should be committed for surrender to United States authorities.”
On Monday, the five-member regional panel of judges, headed by its President Justice Adrian Saunders, also ruled that its previous order which placed a stay on any legal action against the former vice president of the Insurance Corporation of Barbados Limited (ICBL) pending the outcome of this latest application would remain until a determination is made.
Tasker was not present in court for Monday’s hearing, but his legal team including the Trinidad-based Senior Counsel Douglas Mendes had argued that the Court of Appeal was wrong to reject their client’s notice of appeal simply because it was not properly filed as an application for leave to appeal and that the amended document was subsequently lodged a few days late.
“The court ought not to have shut the door on Tasker because his lawyer did it [filed the document] in the wrong way,” Mendes said, adding that because of a technicality, the Court of Appeal should not have been absolute in rejecting the late application and denying his client access to be heard as a matter of natural justice and a constitutional right to a fair hearing.
He contended that the very fact that Tasker had filed a notice to appeal demonstrated his intent to apply for special leave to appeal once that door was open.
“He sought to invoke jurisdiction of the court, but was too late through no fault of his own,” Mendes said, urging the CCJ to accept his client’s plea of “exceptional circumstances” where a legal document was filed late although the litigant was already “knocking on the door” as in this case.
He called on the CCJ to treat the Notice of Appeal as an “Application for Leave filed on time” or, alternatively, extend the time.
But in response, Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions Alliston Seale SC, appearing on behalf of the respondent, suggested that the CCJ should not reverse the lower court’s decision because there are no exceptional circumstances that would merit such a decision.
He cited natural disasters and an island-wide power outage as the type of threshold that would justify a court not enforcing the rules which stipulate the timeframe within which an application for leave to appeal must be lodged.
While acknowledging that there would be other exceptional circumstances, he dismissed Mendes’ submission that human error would also qualify. He contended that to allow “a mistake” to pass as an exceptional circumstance would be to open the “floodgates” for any and everything to qualify.
He said that should this happen, it would dilute the process and have parties constantly reappearing before the CCJ and suggested that the CCJ must draw a line where exceptional circumstances are concerned.
“There is no bar set for exceptional circumstances,” Seale insisted, arguing that the CCJ did not have the power to extend the time for the late application given what was before it.
CMC/af/ir/2023.
