·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Court to rule next week on matter involving Foreign Affairs Minister

3 min read

KINGSTON, Jamaica, Oct 27, CMC – The Supreme Court will on November 2 rule whether or not to strike out a lawsuit filed by a retired United States law enforcement official in a case brought against the jamaica government and the Minister Foreign Affairs Minister Kamina Johnson Smith.

Attorney and former Federal Bureau Investigations (FBI) supervisory special agent, Wilfred Rattigan brought the law suit over the alleged non-disclosure of a US$99,000 donation which Johnson Smith received as a gift to fund aspects of her unsuccessful bid for the position of the London-based Commonwealth secretary general in 2022.

In June 2022, Commonwealth members voted to keep Patricia Scotland as secretary-general of the 54-nation club after some members including Jamaica tried to remove her from the post.

Born in Dominica and raised in Britain, Scotland had a career as a lawyer and politician in Britain before taking up the post of secretary-general of the Commonwealth in 2016. Her term was supposed to finish in 2020, but was extended because the Commonwealth summit scheduled for that year could not take place due to the COVID pandemic.

The American firm, Finn Partners, to whom the funds were paid in three instalments, had reportedly been contracted by local private interests to provide public relations, media relations, and thought leadership services for Johnson Smith’s campaign.

The campaign was reportedly supported by donations from the Musson Group, GraceKennedy, businessman Keith Duncan, and others.

Rattigan sought to obtain full disclosure on the donors and the amount of money that had been put into the campaign of Johnson Smith through the Access to Information Act but said that the Ministry of Finance indicated that it was not in possession of any documents detailing the source of the donations.

Rattigan contends that he obtained documents which detailed that, up to March 30, 2023, Johnson Smith did not declare the gift, which is in breach of the Financial Administration and Audit (FAA) Act.

On April 12, 2023, Rattigan, a Jamaican who resides in the United States, filed the lawsuit in the Supreme Court of Jamaica, seeking to compel Johnson Smith, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Foreign Trade, and the Ministry of Finance and the Public Service to disclose the gift.

“I am not aware of any such suit being filed or served. The allegations are in any event baseless, untrue and defamatory. I remind that defamation, even in social media can result in suits,’ Johnson Smith said in her only public response earlier this year.

But Rattigan’s legal team opted to give notice and both sides made submissions before the court earlier this week and the media was not allowed at the hearing.

Media reports said that the judge also reportedly guided the parties that a gag order was possible in the event that the matters discussed find their way into the public space, including on social media.

Attorney Sophia Bryan, who is representing Rattigan, told the Gleaner newspaper that s guided by the “strong warning” issued by the judge.

In his lawsuit, Rattigan, alleges that Johnson Smith and the foreign affairs ministry failed to comply with the statutory and administrative regulations under the FAA Act with respect to a US$99,000 donation/gift by “corporate Jamaica”.

He is claiming also that the finance ministry failed to take appropriate action to compel Johnson Smith and the foreign affairs ministry to comply with the applicable statutory and administrative regulations.

The former FBI official further contends that Johnson Smith “failed to file a disclosure with the Integrity Commission regarding the donation she received that did not fall within the filing exceptions”.

Rattigan is alleging that, as a beneficiary of a US$99,000 gift/donation, Johnson Smith “should have declared this sum to the Tax Administration Jamaica and paid appropriate taxes thereon”.

Rattigan is also seeking a declaration by the court that Johnson Smith and the Government failed to fulfil requirements of the FAA Act and that she was obligated to report the income to the Tax Administration of Jamaica.

He is also seeking to have the legal and administrative costs of J$350,000 (One Jamaica dollar=US$0.008 cents) to bring the matter to court.

CMC/af/ir/2-23