KINGSTOWN, St. Vincent, April 20, CMC – A Court of Appeal judge on Thursday granted a stay of execution of High Court judge Justice Esco Henry’s decision in the vaccine mandate case.
Acting Justice of Appeal Paul Webster said, in granting the stay, that the government had a reasonable chance of winning an appeal against the decision Justice Esco Henry gave on March 13 in favour of public sector workers.
Justice Henry had ruled that the workers dismissed under the government’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate, which came into effect in December 2021, never stopped having their jobs. She therefore ordered the government to pay them all wages and benefits they would have received had it not been for the government’s decision to terminate them.
Justice Henry further ordered that the government pay punitive damages.
However, the State appealed the decision and applied for a stay of execution of the order, which Justice Webster considered on Tuesday.
In a decision handed down on Thursday, the judge said that on reading the papers submitted in support of and against the stay, the court was satisfied that the government has reasonable prospects of success on appeal, that there is cogent evidence that the appeal will be rendered nugatory unless a stay is granted, and that the appeal concerns matters of public importance.
“And upon the court considering all of the circumstances of the case and determining that the applicants have met the threshold for the grant of a stay of execution, the application for a stay of the judgment and order of Esco Henry J delivered on 13th March 2023 pending the hearing and determination of the appeal is granted,” he said.
The judge noted that in coming to its decision, the court had to consider all the circumstances of the case, including the strength of the appeal, the balance of harm by the grant or refusal of a stay, and whether the appeal will be stifled or rendered nugatory unless a stay is granted.
This week, Jomo Thomas, a lawyer for the workers in the case, said that his team would push for a speedy hearing if the stay of execution was granted.
“And, hopefully, we can get it heard by July because that’s the next time that the [OECS Court of Appeal] returns to St. Vincent,” Thomas said.
“What we don’t want is for the government to get a stay and then for them to engage in some kind of stalling tactics to pressure the workers, to browbeat the workers, to stonewall the workers into applying, reapplying for a job by the mere economic pressure that would come down on them,” the lawyer added.
CMC/kc/ed/2023
