·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

·

Supreme Court rules that three year extension of DPP’s term was legal

2 min read

Paula Llewellyn

KINGSTON, Jamaica, Jul. 31, CMC – The Supreme Court on Monday ruled that a three-year extension granted to Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Paula Llewellyn in 2020 was legal.

A panel comprising three judges – Justices Lorna Shelly-Williams, Simone Wolfe-Reece and Andrea Pettigrew-Collins – handed down their ruling Monday after previously hearing submissions in the Supreme Court.

The development arose after double-murder convict Mervin Cameron filed a suit in February challenging the legality of the DPP’s extension.

Cameron, who is represented by attorney-at-law Hugh Wildman, contended that Llewellyn had been acting in the post illegally for the past three years.

Cameron stated in his affidavit that his attorney, Hugh Wildman, conducted investigations and it was revealed that Llewellyn’s appointment had violated the laws.

The extension that was granted  in 2020, comes to an end on September 21, but with new amendments to the Constitution being passed in the Senate last Friday, moving the retirement age of the DPP to 65, it is not clear if Llewellyn will be staying on as the island’s chief prosecutor until she reaches the age of 65.

Despite Wildman’s declaration concerning the legality of the  extension,  the Supreme Court judges disagreed and denied all declarations.

Reading parts of the judgement in a live audio broadcast, Justice Lorna Shelly-Williams said: “I find that the fact the extension would have taken effect on either the day of the DPP’s birthday, or the day after her birthday is of no moment.

“This is so for two reasons. Firstly, the extension could not have taken place until the end of the DPP’s tenure.

“Secondly, Section 96 1(b) of the Constitution allows for the extension to be granted after the DPP has obtained the age of 60, however, the agreement must have been arrived at before she turned 60,” she said.

The judge found that the agreement to extend the tenure of the DPP “had been concluded before” Llewellyn reached the age of 60.

“That agreement was evidenced by the Extraordinary Gazette of the 26th of August 2020,” said Shelly-Williams, adding that the agreement was made prior to Llewellyn’s September 21, 2020 birthday.

Consequently, the judge determined that declarations being sought by Cameron were not granted.

In her final orders, Shelly-Williams said: “I find that the agreement to extend the tenure of the DPP was arrived at prior to her attaining the age of 60, and of such, there was no breach of Section 96 1(b) of the Constitution.”

The judgement was handed down  as controversy brews over amendments to the constitution to move the age of retirement for the DPP, as well as the auditor general, to 65, with the option for an extension to 70 years.

Several groups, including the main Opposition People’s National Party (PNP), have called for the Government to rethink the amendments. The Senate passed the Bill on Friday to make the amendments lawful.

CMC/jm/kb/2023