KINGSTON, Jamaica, Apr 22, CMC -The senior deputy director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Claudette A Thompson, was named to act as DPP on Monday, after the incumbent Paula Llewellyn, is reported to have informed the authorities that “she is unable to carry out the functions of her office at this time”.
Governor General Sir Patrick Allen, approved the appointment following the recommendation of the newly appointed Public Service Commission (PSC) headed by former senior public servant Patricia Sinclair McCalla.
Llewellyn’s decision to step down followed the Constitutional Court’s ruling last Friday that the second extension of her tenure in office is unconstitutional. The government has since said it would appeal the ruling.
On Sunday, the Office of the Attorney General Chambers indicating that an acting DPP would be named on Monday, said “due to the ambiguity and the consequent uncertainty arising from the Full Court’s judgment in Paulwell and Bunting v the Attorney General SU 223 CV 02499, the Director of Public Prosecutions, DPP, has advised that she is unable to carry out the functions of her office at this time”.
Opposition Leader Mark Golding, who last Friday told a news conference that the post of DPP had become vacant and urged the PSC to move swiftly in recommending someone to act in the position, reiterated his position over the last weekend.
In addition, Golding called for the resignation of Attorney General Derrick McKoy and Justice Minister Delory Chuck, saying that their statements that Llewellyn’s status was not affected by the ruling brought Jamaica to the edge of a constitutional crisis.
“Their actions have fatally undermined their credibility as holders of those important offices,” he said, adding “the continuation of Llewellyn in her post beyond her lawful term is not only unconstitutional but also a grave misstep in governance.
“If the Government adamantly insists on the former DPP continuing to purport to hold that office, her actions would not be validated by law, which would plunge the country into a deeper crisis,” Golding added.
In its ruling on Friday, the Constitutional Court said “a new provision introduced into the Constitution by Section 2(2) of the Act grants the DPP the option to remain in office after age 60 and this gives the DPP a level of authority not envisaged by the Constitution’s framers.”
“The incumbent DPP has already reached the extended retirement age, this means that the application of Section 2(2) cannot lead to another extension in office by way of an election on the part of the incumbent DPP as this is unlawful.”
The Constitutional Court said “the only lawful method to extend the DPP’s tenure remains by way of an agreement between the prime minister and the opposition leader”.
Last July, the government used its majority in the Parliament to amended the retirement ages of the DPP and the Auditor General from 60 to 65. As a result, Llewellyn, whose tenure would have ended in September that year as a result, was given two extra years to remain in office.
CMc/af/ir/2024
