PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Aug 9, CMC – A Trinidad and Tobago High Court judge has ordered the release of 64 Venezuelans, delaying their immediate deportation pending the determination of their judicial review claim.
The Venezuelans were among 200 held at a bar in St. James on the outskirts of the capital that police raised on July 9. Since their detention, they have been kept at the immigration detention facility at the heliport in Chaguaramas, west of here and between July 13 and 24, they were issued with deportation orders.
But their lawyers successfully argued before Justice Ricky Rahim for judicial review asking that the Minister of National Security, Fitzgerald Hinds be restrained from deporting the Venezuelans, as well as having the minister give them permission to remain in this country after they are released.
In the alternative, they wanted an order for their release on orders of supervision pending their application before the UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR) for asylum seeker/refugee status.
On Tuesday, Justice Rahim ruled that the application for judicial review was deemed fit for hearing during the court’s vacation period and also ordered that the Venezuelans be released on orders of supervision. He also said that the state is restrained from enforcing any deportation order against the 64 migrants until the determination of the claim.
“Permission is granted to the applicants to file a claim for judicial review for an order of mandamus that the Respondent/Intended Defendant be compelled to consider whether the applicants should be placed on orders of supervision pending deportation and paragraphs 14, 15, 16 and 17 of the substantive relief set out in the application filed August 2, 2023, on the condition that the applicants file a claim for Judicial Review within 14 days of the date hereof.
“The Respondent/Intended Defendant is restrained from enforcing the orders of deportation against the applicants until a determination of the claim. The Respondent/Intended Defendant shall forthwith issue orders of supervision for each Applicant/Intended Claimant pending determination of the claim,” the orders read.
In their application, attorneys for the 64 argued that as citizens of Venezuela, they were protected by the UNHCR as asylum-seekers or refugees, and despite there being no law locally, Trinidad and Tobago had acceded to the 1951 Geneva Convention on the Status of Refugees and the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees.
Justice Rahim said while the minister was duty-bound to give preference to domestic law in the case where the domestic law does not conform to the treaty obligations of the nation, and a duty to give effect to government policy, he also had a duty to protect every deportee.
He said the unchallenged evidence, at this point, set out events which told of horrible sexual advances and in some cases abuse by members of the Coast Guard, by other guards and by other detainees.
“They tell a tale of depravity and mental anguish as a result.”
“The conditions under which the applicants are detained include but are not limited to overflowing toilets, sleeping on the floor with smelly stagnant water, deprivation of food sent in by relatives, lack of female toiletries and the inability to care for children left with others.”
Regarding Hinds’ duty, Justice Rahim said, “his duty lies with obeying the law. He must of course be satisfied that the deportees would appear for their deportation.
“However, the duty of the office holder extends to protecting not only the vulnerable ones who are detained by the State for the purpose of deportation but every such deportee. In that regard a person who is so detained does not lose his human rights and treatment must be accorded to those detained in keeping with recognised principles of human rights.
“The evidence in this case, should it be true, demonstrates nothing short of inhumane treatment towards some members of the group and their circumstances of detention fall far short of what is to be expected to say the least.
“The damage likely to be suffered by these individuals may as a matter of common sense and logic be exacerbated the longer they are kept in custody under those circumstances awaiting deportation.”
CMC/af/ir/2023