·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

TRINIDAD- Former police commissioner loses defamation and libel claim against newspaper

3 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Apr 18, CMC -Former police commissioner, Gary Griffith, has lost a defamation and libel claim brought against  a newspaper and two journalists including and investigative reporter over a series of articles relating to the issue of firearm licences when he served as Trinidad and Tobago’s top cop.

The articles were published in 2020 and in an oral ruling, Justice Jacqueline Wilson noted that the stories written by investigative reporter Denyse Renne and Rickie Ramdass, and published by the Trinidad Express between October 25-26, 2020, were the product of responsible journalism.

She upheld the defence of the newspaper that the articles were protected by Reynolds privilege.

In his lawsuit, Griffith claimed the journalists and the newspaper had “intentionally or recklessly” brought his good name and the performance of the functions of his office as commissioner into public scandal and disrepute.

But the judge, who said she would be provide in writing her ruling before the end of the week, said Renne had relied on information she received from a confidential source in the police service and took reasonable steps to verify that information, which included making direct inquiries of Griffith, whose responses were published in full.

“The first defendant relied on information from a confidential source she believed to be true and took material steps to verify including calling the claimant for a response,” Justice Wilson said.

The judge also noted that the paper also published in full, a release from the police denying the allegations contained in the articles of a provisional licence being granted to someone under active police investigation.

Justice Wilson said she accepted that Renne took reasonable steps to gather and publish the information, and held that the articles were responsible and fair.

In her evidence, Renne maintained that she practised responsible journalism in her reports as she detailed the investigations she undertook into the information she claimed she received from confidential sources in the TTPS.

“The reason they (the applicants) were not identified is for them not to become criminal targets,” she said.

The judge said while Griffith was entitled to have his reputation protected, it was in this context that the defence of Reynolds privilege struck the appropriate balance between freedom of expression, freedom of the press and the public-interest right to know.

She also said there was a sufficient public-interest element that firearm users’ licences were issued to people of good character and failure to do so posed a threat to public safety.

The judge also said allowances must be made for editorial judgment, as she ruled that the three articles were written and published in the public’s interest and met the standards of responsible journalism.

The article written by  Ramdass, was a report of the police’s press release and contained portions of the two previous articles.

In its defence, the newspaper raised a defence of reportage, but the judge said she did not need to consider it as she upheld the arguments on Reynolds privilege.

Attorney Larry Lalla, hinted that his client would appeal.

CMC/af/ir/2023