·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Judge to rule on proposed tax revenue authority

3 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Jun 3, CMC – Justice Betsy Ann Lambert-Peterson will on Monday decide whether or not to grant an injunction preventing the government from moving ahead with plans to establish the Trinidad and Tobago Revenue Authority (TTRA) incorporating the  Customs and Excise Division (CED) and the Inland Revenue Division (IRD).

The judge last Friday reserved her ruling on the matter after initially indicating that she would have given a ruling on the injunction immediately. But she said that she would need time to consider the new oral submissions from former attorney general Anand Ramlogan SC and Douglas Mendes, SC.

Customs officer Terrisa Dhoray filed the injunction application on May 8, to stop the implementation of section 18 of the TTRA Act, which deals with the enforcement division of the TTRA.

The application contends this forces employees at the IRD and the Customs and Excise Division  to decide by August 1 whether they want to join the TTRA. Dhoray’s challenge to the constitutionality of the TTRA was filed on July 19, 2022.

By legal notice on April 14, President Christine Kangaloo proclaimed certain sections of the TTRA with effect from May 1.

The injunction application seeks to have section 18 stayed pending the hearing and determination of the constitutional claim, as well as an order suspending the date of operationalization of the TTRA.

During his submissions Ramlogan made reference to affidavits filed in the matter by an “expert witness” for the State.

Based on what was stated in the affidavit and that of Finance Minister Colm Imbert, Ramlogan pointed out the only reason why Government wanted to make the replacement was in an attempt to obtain further tax revenue.

“It is not the TTRA that they just want to implement. The reason for doing so is to receive more tax revenue,” said Ramlogan, adding that the Finance Minister “is a puppet master and the strings are attached to his fingers”.

But Mendes urged the High Court to refuse the application for injunctive relief, adding that the question is whether there was even a serious issue to be tried in the first place.

He questioned what prejudice will be suffered by the claimants if the Act were to come into force.

“The Act makes allowances for taxes to be put in a consolidated fund. So you would expect a degree of oversight by the Minister of Finance. There is nothing unusual with the minister exercising a degree of control. What prejudice will they (employees at the IRD and CED) suffer? The answer is none,” said Mendes.

Mendes argued that even if the Act and section 18 were declared unconstitutional, it was unlikely the workers would suffer any prejudice, as they would revert to their original positions and would lose nothing financially, as their remuneration was commensurate with their previous posts, while some were in receipt of better terms and conditions.

“They are asking you to stop or delay the collection of tax revenue,” he said, adding “unless the court declares the act to be unconstitutional, then the authority should be allowed to do its job”.

In February this year, the Finance Minister told Parliament that the decision to establish the TTRA was driven by the need to address deficiencies in the current system stemming from limitations within the Public Service.

“Longstanding deficiencies in the system have been identified and documented in feasibility and performance reports dating back as early as 2002.”

He said the Act enables the TTRA to function according to its mandate, but through a hybrid system, whereby the Enforcement Division will still be guided by the Public Service Commission.

“Through benchmarking against several models, the structure chosen for the TTRA combines the functions of two divisions of the Ministry of Finance, namely the Inland Revenue Division (IRD) and the Customs & Excise Division (CED).

“As one revenue collecting agency, there will be several 2 benefits and synergies, including cost efficiencies, data sharing and improved risk mitigation frameworks,” Imbert said.

CMC/af/nkb/2023