·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Government welcomes Appeal Court ruling

4 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Jan 31, CMC – The Trinidad and Tobago government has welcomed an Appeal Court ruling that on Tuesday dismissed a case by several contracting companies that sought to have the TT$400 million (One TT dollar=US$0.16 cents) claim filed against them by the state-owned Estate Management Business Development Company (EMBD) dismissed.

“I commend the long hard battle that has been fought by the management of the EMBD under the chairmanship of Mr Ronnie Mohammed and the work of the company’s legal team,” said  Attorney General Reginald Armour, SC, noting that the ruling means the contracting companies must now defend themselves in the High Court.

The case will now continue after the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal against a High Court  judge’s refusal to throw out the EMBD’s lawsuit on the grounds that the state-owned  company did not give particulars relating to allegations raised.

In a statement, Armour said had the group of contractors succeeded, they would not have been required to give evidence at trial. He said they will now have take the witness stand and face cross-examination.

The contractors, as well as several others named in the claim, including former housing and urban development minister, Dr Roodal Moonilal, have been ordered to file their defences by March 20.

The four contracting companies and their principals lost their appeal against a judge’s refusal to strike out the TT$400 million cartel case which centres on contracts awarded by the EMBD in the run-up to the 2015 general election.

The three-member Court of Appeal comprising Justices Charmaine Pemberton, Peter Rajkumar and Vasheist Kokaram dismissed the companies’ appeal.

This was the third panel of Appeal Court judges to hear the challenge to Justice James Aboud’s ruling in 2020 after Justice Maria Wilson recused herself on June 29, the day before she and Justices of Appeal Nolan Bereaux and Mark Mohammed were expected to deliver their ruling.

Wilson’s decision stemmed from her brother, attorney Fulton Wilson’s former appointment as a director of the EMBD board from 2015-2021, when the state-owed company filed the lawsuit against the companies and Moonilal.

In August 2020, Justice Aboud, dismissed preliminary applications by the five contractors – TN Ramnauth, Namalco, Kallco, Mootilal Ramhit and Sons Contracting Ltd, and Fides Ltd – which sought to have the EMBD detail allegations against them so they could fairly mount their defence, or strike out the claims.

In June 2021, two Appeal Court judges heard the procedural appeal but were unable to arrive at a unanimous decision. The matter was referred to the full three-member panel of judges.

The lawsuit centres on 12 contracts for rehabilitating roads and infrastructure which were granted to five contractors before the 2015 general election.

The EMBD countersued the contractors, claiming that they, as well as contractors Fides and Namalco, stand accused of conspiring with Moonilal, former EMBD chief executive officer Gary Parmassar, former divisional manager Madhoo Balroop and engineer Andrew Walker to obtain contracts corruptly.

The parties in the counter-suit had previously agreed to abide by the Appeal Court’s ruling in the contractors’ appeal and will now be expected to file their various defences.

The EMBD’s case against the contractors was that they engaged in unlawful acts to secure the 12 contracts between May-August 2015.

In its ruling on Tuesday, the Court of Appeal held that sufficient information was pleaded in the lawsuit to permit arguments at a trial. The ruling said an inference could be drawn relating to the losses the EMBD sustained in two of the contracts.

The Appeal Court also ruled that despite claims to the contrary, the EMBD had pleaded that the work performed by the contractors for another project was worthless and of no value.

It said while the pleadings for other contracts did not quantify the loss, it was “expressly pleaded that such actual pecuniary loss did occur.”

“There can be no doubt therefore that the appellants had been made aware, on the pleadings as they stand, that EMBD claims to have sustained actual pecuniary loss of the types identified as a result of the unlawful means conspiracy…”

“That loss, though not yet quantified – a different matter altogether – was the result of inflated prices, over certification, deficient and omitted works. The cause of action was complete and the trial judge was therefore clearly correct not to strike out that claim,” the Court of Appeal ruled , adding  there was “extensive pleading of highly unusual correlations in the bids submitted by the corporate appellants.

“They, therefore, have sufficient information to respond to allegations that the alleged concerted bids and claims were attributable to the corporate appellants,” the Court of Appeal ruled.

CMC/ag/ir/2024