·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Privy Council rules against St. Lucia’s Deputy Prime Minister

3 min read

LONDON, Jun 13, CMC -The London-based Privy Council Tuesday dismissed an appeal filed by St. Lucia’s Deputy Prime Minister, Dr. Ernest Hilaire, on whether a particular section of the Civil Code of St. Lucia allows the importation of United Kingdom statute law into local law in relation to contracts, quasi-contracts and torts.

Hilaire had filed a claim against former prime minister Allen Chastanet  for defamation in the St. Lucia High Court on March 20, 2017.

A defence was filed by Chastanet on May 2, 2017, in which he placed substantial reliance on the Defamation Act 2013 of the United Kingdom, which he contended was imported into St. Lucia law by virtue of Article 917A of the Civil Code Cap 4:01 of the Civil Code.

But by application filed on August 16, 2018,  the defendant applied to strike out the claimant’s claim on the basis that it disclosed no reasonable ground for bringing the claim.

The claimant filed an application on 3 September 2018 to strike out the defendant’s defence on the basis that it disclosed no reasonable defence to the claim as the defence was predicated on the Act which was not applicable to St. Lucia.

The basis for the objection was that the Article 917A only imported the common law of England and not English statute law.

It was agreed at the hearing of the applications that the issue of the importation of the Act should be heard as a preliminary issue as it would determine the viability of each party’s pleadings.

In the High Court, it was determined that Article 917A of the Civil Code did not import the Act into S.t Lucian law and in an appeal, the higher court held that Article 917A of the Civil Code does allow for the importation of both common law and statute law in relation to contracts, quasi contracts and torts.

When the matter came before the Privy Council, the island’s highest court, it concluded that  article 917A is valid and that in principle it imports both English statute law and English common law into St Lucia.

The Privy Council said that it would consider the appellant’s case that such importation is precluded by inconsistencies between specific aspects of English defamation law and the law of St. Lucia.

But in its 23 page ruling, the Privy Council said the Board it would “humbly advise…that the appeal should be dismissed”.

Chastanet has not yet issued any statement regarding the Privy Council ruling, but in a statement issued in Castries, Hilaire  described the Privy Council ruling as “unfortunate” adding “it undermines the legal jurisprudence of St. Lucia and indeed exposes lawyers in St. Lucia to professional negligence law suits for advising their clients on what they thought was the proper law of the land.

“Moreso, St. Lucians would not even know which laws applies to St. Lucia as they would have to research English Laws each time, they feel aggrieved to know if they have any legal grounds for action.”

He acknowledged that while the ruling cannot be appealed any further “and as such all that is left to be done is await the advice of the Attorney General on the corrective measures that needs to be taken to ensure that the law of St. Lucia is certain and not left with such ambiguity.

“I believe that our Constitution is supreme and that we have the sole right to make laws for ourselves. It is left to St Lucia to regain an important aspect of our independence in making it beyond any doubt, that our law as an independent and sovereign state, would always apply.”

He said as it pertains to the his defamation case against Chastanet “I will be consulting my lawyers on the next steps in the hearing”.

CMC/ad/ir/2023