·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Opposition Leader files motion against Speaker and Attorney General

3 min read

CASTRIES, St. Lucia, May 9, CMC – Opposition Leader, Allen Chastanet, is asking the High Court to declare that the Parliament has no power to suspend a member for “an indefinite period save and except” in accordance with the St. Lucia Constitution and or the House of Assembly Act.

Chastanet is also asking the High Court to issue a declaration that his May 2 indefinite suspension “was unconstitutional and null and void and of no effect.

“Alternatively, a declaration that the suspension was effected in a manner that violated the claimant’s rights ….and, was accordingly, illegal, unlawful, null and void and of no effect”.

Chastanet also wants the High Court to rule that the Speaker, Claudius Francis, “had no power” to order his detention when he attempted to leave “the Chamber…or at all”.

He wants the High Court to declare that the arrest or the detention “was unlawful and violated” and that his right under the Constitution “to personal liberty, freedom from arrest and free movement in St. Lucia was accordingly illegal, unlawful and unconstitutional”.

Last week, Chastanet defended his decision not to offer an apology for statements alleging government corruption even as he was being suspended by Parliament over the matter.

“I was sanctioned by the Parliament and I was forced to walk out to defend democracy in this country,” Chastanet said in a post on his social media platform, adding “I refuse to give an apology for a lie that was told by (Housing Minister) Richard Frederick”.

The Speaker, citing the Standing Orders  sought to determine what sanctions, if any, could be imposed on Chastanet for disregarding the authority of the chair.

“I am the judge in this Chamber and I would ask you to withdraw the statements that I have read,” the Speaker said, but Chastanet stood his position, saying he would not.

But as he prepared to walk out of the Chamber, the Speaker instructed the police officers on duty to prevent him from leaving.

However Chastanet exited the Chamber, followed by two police officers, returning a short time later . The Leader of Government Business,  Dr. Ernest Hilaire, said Chastanet should be asked to apologise and failure to do so, should not be allowed into the Chamber.

But the Speaker indicated that the Chair’s discretion was limited only to a maximum of the next sitting, explaining that there was no such limitation on the House.

“If you ask me to put your question to the House, which is that the member – the Honourable Allen Chastanet, … be asked to withdraw the statement, issue an apology, failing which this Honourable House shall rule that he is not to be allowed within the precincts of the House until he does so – Is that your question, Leader of Government Business?”

Parliament later voted in favour of the suspension.

Chastanet said he is also seeking an injunction preventing the Speaker “whether by himself, his servants or agents….from excluding…or preventing” him from attending any sittings of the Parliament or entering the precincts of the House.

The Opposition Leader is also seeking damages for breaches of his constitutional rights as well as for wrongful arrest or detention and for “unlawful suspension from the House”.

He is also asking the High Court to have Francis and the Attorney General, who is the other defendant in the matter, to meet the costs of the court action.

Earlier this year, Chastanet called for the resignation of the Speaker after the High Court on January 31, ruled that he had no power to refer to the Committee of Privileges any complaint made by a member of the House of Assembly against another member in respect of privileges or contempt.

CMC/if/ir/2023