·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Government confident that lawsuit against extension of DDP tenure will fail

3 min read

KINGSTON, Jamaica, Aug 9, CMC – The Jamaica government Wednesday said it remains confident that the lawsuit filed by two executive members of the main opposition People’s National Party (PNP) challenging the amendment to the Constitution allowing for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Paula Llewellyn to remain in office for an extra two years, will not succeed.

The PNP members want the Supreme Court to declare the amendment,  which moves the retirement age of the DPP as well as the Auditor General from 60 to 65 years as unconstitutional, null and void.

But,  Minister without Portfolio in the Office of the Prime Minister with Responsibility for Information, Robert Morgan,  told the weekly Cabinet news conference that he wanted to scho the sentimes of the Minister of Justice this morning that the government acted within the law and constitutionally .

“There is no question about the legal process that the government put forward. What is clear to the government is that the opposition is carrying out a personal vendetta against an individual.

“They have filed a claim in relation to one individual when the law was changed to affect two individuals. The public needs to ask themselves why target this person. They have not provided any nevidence of impropiety, they have not provided any evidence of inapproprtiateness of behaviour,” Morgan told reporters.

“As a matter of fact  everyone in the legal fraternity or at least most of them, who have given an appraisal of the work of this individual has spoken about the transformative approach that this person has had”.

He said the DPP has been involved in several “major ground breaking trials which have caused many criminals to be now behind bars.

“So we are a bit interested in hearing what the Court has to say, and we respect the Court, but we do not believe based on the frivilous grounds on which this claim was laid …will be successful,” Morgan added.

The claimants, Member of Parliament Phillip Paulwell and Peter Bunting, are seeking a declaration that Llewellyn should not be allowed to remain in office beyond September when the three-year extension she was given in 2020 expires.

They are seeking declarations that Section 2 of the Constitution (Amendment of sections 96(1) and 121(1) Act 2023 was enacted for an improper purpose and is therefore inconsistent with the Constitution, null and void.

A declaration is being sought that Section 2 of the Act would have the effect of circumventing, undermining and/or contradicting the constitutionally mandated process for the extension of the term of office of a DPP, and is therefore inconsistent with the Constitution, null and void. The claimants are seeking a declaration that Zection 2 of the Act was enacted in breach of the separation of powers principle and is therefore inconsistent with the Constitution, null and void.

In the alternative or in furtherance to the declarations or consequent to the grant of the declarations, the claimants are seeking an order that section 2(1) of the Act be read and construed as not applying to a person who is the DPP as at the date of commencement of the Act and that section 2 ( 2) be struck out.

CMC/ag/ir/2023