GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Jul 18, CMC – An opposition legislator is questioning the motive behind the Guyana government’s decision to have the families of the 20 children killed during a fire at a dormitory at a secondary school in May, sign an agreement that could make it much more difficult to obtain compensation from the state.
“When you look at the text of the agreement, what they have essentially asked these families to sign is that for five million dollars (One Guyana dollar=US$0.004 cents), you would waive your right to any future claim for any injuries resulting from this unfortunate incident,” Amanza Walton-Desir said in a video statement.
In a statement on Monday, the Office of the Attorney General said the Irfaan Ali government pledges to continue to offer support and assistance in various ways to enable the families to continue to cope with, and recover from, this horrendous tragedy.
“In this regard, many family members requested cash which they could use to make purchases that would enhance their ability to continue to provide for their families. In response to these requests, Government offered each family financial assistance, and the families were requested to sign an agreement having received independent legal advice”.
The statement said that the process of providing this financial assistance is ongoing and that in the agreement itself, government pledged to continue to offer such support as may be necessary to the victims and their families.
According to the agreement, “the Government of Guyana hereby offers to the parent/guardian of the victim the sum of five million dollars ($5,000,000) as a form of financial assistance which shall constitute a settlement of all claims and causes of actions on account of all injuries resulting in death and not resulting in death, that resulted from the fire of the 21st May 2023 at the Mahdia Secondary School Dormitory”.
The agreement further removes any liability any party to the agreement caused by, arising from, or connected to, the fire at the Mahdia Secondary School Dormitory.
Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs Anil Nandlall in an interview here said that the five million dollars for each family was not compensation or an effort to return the child, heal injuries or psychological trauma.
“This is not a compensation because government really cant and it will be insensitive to think that the government can compensate for the tremendous loss, and suffering and anguish that those people went through,” he said.
But the opposition legislator said the government was indebted to the surviving families, saying “these students died whilst in the care and custody of the state and so the state has not been doing a favour to the family.
“These families left their children in the care of the state trusting that they would be taken care of,” said Walton-Desir, who is also an attorney.
She told viewers that a Commission of Inquiry into the deadly fire in the shortest possible time was the only decent approach and accused the government of getting the surviving families to sign the agreements because of the evidence contained in the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) report on Guyana’s dormitories and a Guyana Fire Service report.
“The government has to be insulated because they know, they are aware that they failed, that their officers failed, that that dormitory was flagged by the fire service as being a fire hazard,” she said, fearing that the children’s families would eventually have to engage in legal battles to secure compensation.
“It would appear to me at first blush that the terms of this agreement preclude them from proceeding further unless, of course, they can make certain legal arguments that the inequality of the bargaining power at the time, the unconscionable nature of the agreement would allow them to have it waived but that is an unnecessary battle that they will have to fight,” she said.
A secondary school girl, who allegedly caused the death of 19 of her schoolmates when she allegedly set the dormitory of the Mahdia Secondary School on fire has since been charged with murder.
Guyanese law prohibits the naming of juvenile accused persons or convicts. But it allows for her to be charged with murder since she is older than 14 years.
The statement from the Office of the Attorney General said that the Commission of Inquiry (COI) into the circumstances surrounding the deadly blaze, will be established, and that “it will, if it considers necessary, review all the facts and circumstances relating to the event, in accordance with its Terms of Reference”.
CMC/gt/ir/2023
