·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Parliament approves legislation aimed at improving justice in Guyana

3 min read

GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Apr 25, CMC – The Guyana Parliament late Monday gave the green light to the Court of Appeal (Amendment) Bill aimed at improving the efficiency of court proceedings and increasing the number of appellate court judges to at least nine.

The Court of Appeal (Amendment) Bill of 2022 amends section 34(1) of the Court of Appeal Act, Cap. 3:01, which presently provides that the judges of the Court of Appeal shall include no more than five Justices of Appeal.

Attorney General and Minister of Legal Affairs, Mohabir Anil Nandlall, SC, said the increase in the complement of judges is long overdue, amid a tremendous increase in litigation.

“In my view, the propensity to litigate in Guyana has grown progressively over the years. It is, therefore, both unreasonable and impossible to expect the same number of judges to cope efficiently in the face of such an increase in workload.

“Our government has been a willing and reliable partner in supporting the judiciary in every initiative designed to improve the justice system and bring to its processes greater dispatch,” he told legislators.

Parliament Monday night also passed the Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill of 2022  to ensure the constitutional rights of accused persons are protected and follows an earlier ruling by the Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) which is the country’s highest court.

The CCJ ruling was given in the Marcus Bisram v The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) matter where Bisram, who was accused of murder, was discharged by the magistrate who heard the evidence at a preliminary inquiry (PI).  Consequently, the DPP directed the magistrate to reopen the PI and later to commit Bisram to trial, with which the magistrate complied.

Bisram appealed to the CCJ, which agreed that Section 72 of the Criminal Law (Procedure) Act violates the separation of powers and is also inconsistent with Article 144 of the Constitution, which governs a person’s right to a fair hearing.

The amendment now provides that the DPP may make an application to a judge of the High Court for a warrant to arrest and commit an accused person who was discharged by a magistrate under section 69 or 71A (4) of the Principal Act.

This application must be made within three months of receipt from the magistrate, of the authenticated copy of the depositions and any other statements or documents involved in the proceedings.

The judge may only grant this application if he or she believes such an action is warranted, based on the evidence placed before the magistrate who discharged the accused. Both the DPP and the discharged person have the right to appeal the decision.

Nandlall said the new bill prioritises the importance of separation of powers and constitutional rights.

“We believe that this bill accurately captures the jurisprudential aspects of the CCJ’s decision and directives as well as it occurs due protection to the constitutional rights of the accused person,”  he added.

The CCJ had recommended that section 72 be amended to reflect that the DPP may apply ‘ex parte’  to a judge of the Supreme Court for an order that the discharged person be arrested and committed if the judge is of the view that the material placed before them justified such a course of action.

“If an accused person is charged with murder and placed before a magistrate, and rightly or wrongly is discharged by that magistrate, therefore is free once again, and the presumption of innocence has not been dismantled, so he is presumed innocent,” Nandllall said.

“I believe that it would be repugnant to go before a judge ex parte and reinstitute a criminal charge, and get an arrest warrant issued against that person and commit him to stand trial before a judge and jury ex parte, meaning, without him being heard,” he added.

“The DPP can make the application, and if the judge wishes to hear the application ex parte, that is up to the judge. But if the judge wishes to hear the defendant…we should let the judge determine,” he said.

CMC/ad/ir/2023