GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Jun 19, CMC – A High Court judge Monday dismissed a challenge filed by the opposition questioning the validity of the Natural Resources Fund (NRF) due to the absence of the Mace in the National Assembly.
Justice Narendra Singh in a written judgement said that the legislation had been passed in the National Assembly on December 29, 2021, saying it is clear from the evidence that the Mace is nothing more than a relic intended only to be a symbolic representation in the National Assembly.
“It is illogical to believe that the presence or absence of a length of metal can determine the legitimacy of acts done by persons elected by the citizens of the country pursuant to their elected duties,” the judge said.
“The presence of the mace in the National Assembly is not mandated by the Constitution of the Laws of Guyana and therefore its absence cannot result in the passage of the Bill being unconstitutional or unlawful.”
Opposition Chief Whip, Christopher Jones and trade unionist Norris Witter had brought the motion before the High Court with their lawyers arguing that the NRF legislation was not passed for several reasons including that the absence of the Mace, the proceedings of the National Assembly went beyond the stipulated time without a motion, there were inadequate consultations on the Bill and that the Speaker refused to allow opposition legislators to participate in the debate of the Bill.
But Justice Singh did not agree with the arguments and provided reasons for each of the issues he dismissed.
With regards to the proceedings of the Assembly going beyond the stipulated time, the judge noted that time for the sittings of the National Assembly is not mandated by the Constitution or the Laws of Guyana and as such that cannot affect the legality or constitutionality of the Bill passed.
In dismissing the argument that not sufficient consultation had been had with the public, the High Court noted that consultations with stakeholders or the citizenry of Guyana are not required before enacting legislation since legislators are elected to serve as representatives of the people.
But it was however, noted that there were avenues for engagements including the debate of the Bill in the House.
The Court also found that the Speaker did not deny any member of the Opposition the opportunity to participate in the debate on the Natural Resource Fund Bill.
“We are quite disappointed with the Judge’s ruling, but as you know we have not had a chance to hear the reasons. We were just given a copy of the judgment but this case deals with a number of very important constitutional issues,” said Senior Counsel, Roysdale Forde.
However, Attorney General, Anil Nandlall told reporters that the ruling comes as no surprise and that the records would show that the opposition, in opposing the NRF legislation “broke” the Mace while behaving in a “riotous, vulgar and reprehensible” manner.
“So, they came here and asked the Court, essentially, to confirm their vulgarity. Now, of course, they did not advance much legal arguments because hardly, they exist any. The Court rejected all their arguments and upheld our submissions.
“Firstly, mace or absence of mace has nothing to do with the legislative power of the Parliament to make laws. Parliament is driven by the elected officials, who are there elected by the people, and are governed by the Constitution,” Nandlall told reporters.
Justice Singh awarded GUY$250,000 (One Guyana dollar=US$0.004 cents) in costs to each defendant against each claimant. These are to be paid on or before July 19, this year.
Earlier this year, a High Court judge dismissed a motion by eight opposition legislators who sought to overturn their suspension for their role in the December unrest at the legislative chambers.
The fracas in the National Assembly occurred while Finance Minister Dr. Ashni Singh was outlining the benefits of the new Natural Resources Fund legislation.
In her ruling, Justice Damon Younge said the court cannot intervene in the work of the Parliament as the Standing Orders are not subject to the provisions of the Guyana Constitution.
In her ruling the judge said the National Assembly’s Standing Orders are only subjected to the Constitution if there are regulations and the Parliament must be able to conduct its affairs without interference from the court.
The eight opposition legislators had argued that they were not given a right to a hearing by the bipartisan Privileges Committee which recommended that they be suspended for their part in the incident on December 29, 2021.
CMC/gt/ir/2023