GEORGETOWN, Guyana, Jun 25, CMC – Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) Judge, Jacob Wit is calling for the establishment of a pre-trial Chamber to address the protracted delay in accused persons on bail and on remand awaiting trial.
The prominent Dutch jurist from the Netherlands and Netherlands Antilles, was the featured speaker at a public lecture on “Re-thinking Criminal Justice” at the Authur Chung Center here, on Saturday.
“Regionally, the delays are such that they are simply unacceptable. In some cases, accused persons are on remand for more than 10 years, still waiting for their trial,” he said.
Justice Wit harshly criticised the manner in which the Lower Courts decide whether persons should be remanded, placed on bail or freed after a protracted delay in their trial, stating that, “looking at the decisions taken in the pre-trial phase, they seem to be somewhat haphazard, chaotic and unsystematic”.
He recommended that pre-trial procedures be taken more seriously and dealt with in an organised way to allow for accused persons on remand to be tried within six month to one year of their arrest, and those freed on bail within 18 months to two years.
The CCJ judge also recommended that the post of pre-trial Chamber be created which should consist of a High Court judge assisted by magistrates which should be monitoring all criminal cases of remand prisoners and bailed persons.
He proffered that a pre-trial Chamber would allow the court system and the prosecution to ease the back-log of cases through strict case management in the pre-trial phase.
“This is the process of sifting out the weaker cases and keeping the stronger ones,” he said, further recommending that the stronger cases be determined by plea bargains and trials.
He said the Chamber should have the power to give the prosecution deadlines to avoid them automatically perverting cases.
“Both the prosecution and defense would be under constant supervision by the court to move the cases forward and to secure and protect the quality of the evidence whichever way it goes,” he said.
He highlighted the judicial system of Suriname where cases must go to trial after the accused is on remand for five months and most are finished with a sentence or acquittal within ten and a half months.
“I don’t think there is any place in the Commonwealth Caribbean that can say that and in my view it is nothing to do with civil or common law.
“It’s a matter of organising the pre-trial phase to be brave enough to take such decisions,” Justice Wit said.
He added that if cases are discharged by the pre-trial Chamber, because of a lack of evidence, suspects could be re-arrested based on fresh evidence, prosecuted and face trial.
Justice Wit, said the system that allows accused individuals to remain on remand longer than the maximum imprisonment for the alleged offence “has nothing to do with justice”.
He contrasted that with many accused persons who are free on bail not because they deserve it, but because the remand prisons are full and unable accommodate more prisoners.
The CCJ judge said eventually remanded prisoners are released in keeping with the constitution that states that if an accused person on remand is not tried within a reasonable time, he or she should be released unconditionally or upon reasonable condition.
CMC/nhb/2023
