·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

Attorney General critical of ruling that frees former former finance minister

3 min read

GEORGETOWN, Guyana, May 17, CMC – Attorney General Anil Nandlall, has criticized the ruling of a city magistrate, who on Tuesday upheld a no case submission filed on behalf of former finance minister Winston Jordan, freeing him of a charge that he had misconducted himself in public office during the last administration.

Nandlall, a Senior Counsel, said while in recent time he had been “forced to undertake the unfortunate task to offer genuine critical commentary on the manner in which certain criminal cases are being adjudicated upon in the Magistracy,” Tuesday’s ruling by Magistrate Leron Daly “ has regrettably” provided “another such occasion”.

Jordan, who had been on three million dollars (One Guyana dollar=US$0.008 cents) bail  since his initial court appearance in 2021, had been accused of  willfully misconducting himself by acting recklessly when he signed the Transfer of Property order for the government’s holding company, National Industrial and Commercial Investments Limited (NICIL) between February 26 and July 31, 2020 in favour of BK International.

The court was told that BK International had paid GUY$20.2 million for the property valued at over five billion dollars.

Jordan has always maintained his innocence, and has repeatedly accused the current government of filing a “trumped-up” charge in an effort to silence his regular criticism of the government’s handling of the economy since it took office

When the matter came up before Magistrate Daly, she upheld the no-case submission that was filed by Jordan’s attorneys, Senior Counsel Roysdale Forde and Dawn Cush.  The magistrate said Jordan was appointed as a “Minister” and not a “Public Officer.”

However in his statement, Nandlall said the “learned Magistrate predicated her ruling on a finding in law that as Minister of Finance, Mr. Jordan was not a Public Officer, an important ingredient in the offence”.

He said based upon inquiries that he made, “I am informed that the learned Magistrate received from the State written submissions supported by judicial authorities, including, a written ruling delivered by the Chief Justice (ag) Roxane George SC” in a matter involving the Senior Finance Minister Dr. Ashni Singh a few years ago.

”In this case, Dr. Ashni Singh was charged with the identical offence regarding certain acts he performed while he was Minister of Finance and placed before the Georgetown Magistrates’ Court. The validity of the charge was challenged in the High Court on the identical ground, that is, as Minister of Finance, Dr. Singh was not a Public Officer for the purposes of the charge.”

He said the matter was heard by acting Chief Justice Roxane George SC who,” after hearing detailed submissions from both counsel for Dr. Singh and the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), ruled that Dr. Singh may be charged with the offence of Misconduct in Public Office notwithstanding that he was a Minister.

“This ruling was delivered on November 18, 2020 and was never appealed. It remains the law on the issue,” the Attorney General said, adding that first-year law students are taught that the doctrine of Stare Decisis, by virtue of which the decision of the High Court on a particular principle of law, is binding precedent on a Magistrate, to the extent that the Magistrate has no jurisdictional freedom to depart from that High Court’s decision.

He said that the two cases involving Jordan and Singh “are almost identical in both issues of facts and law, and the decision of the learned Chief Justice in the Singh and Brassington case constitutes a binding precedent on the learned Magistrate.

“Clearly, the learned Magistrate erred in law by refusing to follow the decision of the learned Chief Justice. Such an elementary egregious error has excited great public concern within a few hours and inevitably will shake the public confidence in the administration of justice,” he said, adding “to the public, it appears that they are different standards being applied to different persons by the administration of justice”.

Nandlall said that the ruling by the magistrate has the effect of Jordan walking “free after vesting title of a State asset valued at over US $40 million to a private company for which the State received a mere US $100,000”.

CMC/gt/ir/2023