ST. GEORGE’S, Grenada, May 19, CMC – A High Court judge has ordered former prime minister Dr. Keith Mitchell to pay EC$130,000 (One EC dollar=US$0.37 cents) in damages to a former legislator, who successfully, who successfully sued him over public statements he made in June 2014.
Mitchell has already indicated that he will file an appeal against the ruling of Justice Raulston L. A. Glasgow that he must pay Patrick Simmons EC$100,000 in damages for defamation, aggravated damages in the sum of EC$30,000.00 as well as interest on the total sum of EC$130,000 at the rate of six per cent per annum.
In addition, Mitchell, who had been one of the Caribbean longest serving head of government until June last year, when his party lost the general election, has to pay costs totalling EC$18,750.
The lawsuit stemmed from a June 1, 2014 town hall meeting, where Mitchell in answering a question from the audience that included Grenadians residing overseas, that “it is a fact” that land had been bought by the then government from a company “which had some persons who were ministers of Government in that company”.
Mitchell told the public meeting that he had a “fundamental problem with this” and that he could “ see how any member of my Government will go and buy a piece of land knowing that the Government wants it, buy it and then sell it to the Government.
“ Clearly, they are not buying it for charity. They clearly was (sic) buying it as a part really of making money…,” Mitchell said, adding that the facts about the sale “are there.
“The company is there. I’m talking from Cabinet papers my dear. I’m sorry t,” he said, urging the questioner to ask Simmons if he wasn’t a member of the government at the time.
Simmons argued that the words uttered by Mitchell were defamatory and that he “knew the slanderous effect of those words”.
He also argued that the words uttered by Mitchell in their natural and ordinary meaning or innuendo referred to him in his capacity as a minister of government and meant or intended to convey as fact “certain members of the Grenadian Government preceding his administration bought land which they knew was needed by the Government for the benefit of the State and then sold it to Government for profit”.
He said that the statement by Mitchell also sought to promote as a fact that Simmons, as a government minister “engaged in corrupt practices or in a corrupt transaction for profit at the expense of the Government and people of Grenada”.
In his ruling, the judge said he found “the most glaring evidence of aggravation is exhibited by the failure to apologise,” noting that the attorney for Simmons had in his pre-action letter dated August 22, 2014 had “demanded a written apology from Dr. Mitchell which was refused..”.
The judge said that Mitchell acknowledged that his statements were”erroneous in material regards for instance, Mr. Simmons’ membership of the company.
“In my view, this acknowledgment should have been forthcoming much earlier. Certainly, the company documents which showed who were the shareholders of the company, ought to have impelled Dr. Mitchell to immediately retract his assertions about Mr. Simmons’ involvement in the alleged affair,” he added.
The judge said also that equally, the Cabinet papers which Mitchell relied on in his evidence “ought to have advised him at least by the time of disclosure that his assessment of the conduct of the 2008 to 2013 Government was flawed in material respects.
“He ought to have issued some retraction, correction or apology. His failure to do so, in my view, added to the injury caused to Mr. Simmons’ reputation and must be compensated for as aggravated damages”.
CMC/ls/ir/2023
