HAMILTON, Bermuda, Jul 31, CMC – Four years after the London-based Privy Council struck down his conviction of murder, saying there was “no risk” a serious miscarriage of justice had occurred, Wolda Gardner, has been given the green light to go again before the court to challenge the constitutionality of his conviction.
Gardner was jailed for the premeditated murder of Malcolm Augustus in 2012 and using a firearm to commit an indictable act.
He had argued unsuccessfully before the Court of Appeal that his conviction was unconstitutional because the jury selection process had breached his right to a fair trial. But the Court of Appeal found that there were some “genuinely disputable issues” in the judgment so it would be wrong to refuse leave to appeal.
Gardner was sentenced in July 2015 to 20 years in jail for killing Augustus, who was shot dead on Christmas eve 2012. Police found a mobile phone with Gardner’s DNA in the area of the shooting, along with a hat belonging to a second man, who was cleared of charges in connection with the shooting.
They also discovered a series of short phone calls and messages between the two men on the evening of the murder. Gardner said the calls were in relation to Christmas hampers.
However, he was found guilty by a majority verdict of 11-1.
He unsuccessfully appealed the case in 2017, and in 2019 the Privy Council in London declined to hear the matter, saying there was “no risk” a serious miscarriage of justice had occurred.
Gardner had argued that the language of Section 15 of the Constitution would allow a retroactive application to the Supreme Court.
While Gardner applied to the Supreme Court under Section 15, Chief Justice Narinder Hargun found that any appeal should go to the upper court and that the same exceptional circumstances test would apply in both courts.
CMC/ag/ir/2023
