BELMOPAN, Belize, Jul 12, CMC – Former prime minister Dean Barrow has taken the Elections and Boundaries Commission (EBC) to task after it warned the media that any publication and or dissemination of the report on the re-distribution of constituencies will be considered as “a violation of the privileges and Standing Order of the House of the Representatives”.
Prime Minister John Briceño says Parliament will have to decide whether or not to accept the re-division exercise carried out by the EBC even as the main opposition United Democratic Party in a statement said the EBC is “attempting to suppress the publication of the redistricting proposal it will present to Parliament on July 13, 2023”.
In a statement, the EBC said that it had completed the re-division exercise to consider the distribution of the population throughout Belize and make proposals for dividing Belize into electoral divisions in such a way that each electoral division shall have “as nearly as may be an equal number of persons eligible to vote”with the total number of electoral divisions not being less than 28.
It said that the Belize Constitution requires the proposals to be laid before the Parliament by the EBC chairman Oscar Sabido-Puga who “will hereafter present a copy of the report containing the Proposals of the Commission to the National Assembly to be laid on the table of the House of Representatives.
“In the interim period, the media and any other person are informed that publication and/or dissemination of the Report, prior to the Report being laid on the Table of the House of the Representatives, is a violation of the privileges and Standing Order of the House of the Representatives.”
But Barrow, an attorney, who served as prime minister here from 2008 to 2020, when he bowed out of active politics, said while he does not have a recollection of the particular Standing Order right away “it strikes me that the Standing Orders are to govern proceedings in the Chamber, in the House and in the Senate and if members of the legislature breach the Standing Orders, they can be called to account.
“I’m not quite sure how the media would be breaching the Standing Orders of Parliament if in pursuit of the media’s duty, in pursuit of freedom of the press, the media were to publish excerpts or perhaps the entire report from the redistricting committee.”
Barrow said that “once the media got hold of that report…I think that’s a poor effort at trying to suppress the media from discharging its duty in a democracy and clearly that effort, I’m sure, has already backfired, if not, it will backfire”.
Opposition Leader, Shyne Barrow has also criticised the EBC over its position, saying “there is no way that any Standing Order from the House could bind any public member, any media member”.
He says while he is not aware of who is advising the government or the EBC chairman, “it’s absolutely absurd that they would have put out that press release in an attempt, in my view, to silence the voice of the media and the public, and suppress freedom of speech and freedom of the press.
“The fact of the matter is the Election and Boundaries Commission are not a part of the legislature. The fact of the matter is the Constitution of Belize prohibits the commingling of the legislature and the Election and Boundaries Commission in subsection 58 section 62.
“ Any member of the House would have to vacate their seat if they are to be involved in anything having to do with elections. So the House of Representatives and elections and boundaries have zero to do with each other. As far as the standing orders pertaining to members of the House, such as me, there is no standing order prevents me from disclosing information to the public as far as what has been proposed to our election and boundaries commissioners., The Opposition Leader added.
CMC/ag/ir/2023
