NASSAU, Bahamas, Nov 27, CMC -A High Court judge has dismissed a government bid to strike out a multi-million dollar claim over allegations that it pirated the design of the national flag, saying the claim by a copyright holder “contains a number of curious features” that need to be resolved by a full trial of the matter.
Justice Neil Brathwaite over the last weekend in his ruling did not specific the “curious features” but rejected arguments from the government that the US$328.5 million claim by James Alexander Darling for copyright violation should be dismissed.
The judge said that the Crown Proceedings Act’s section five (2) did not give the government “blanket” protection for copyright and intellectual property rights violations.
The judge also dismissed Darling’s argument that the government’s defence to his action be struck out because it merely contained “bare denials and non-admissions”.
The Supreme Court, while finding that the government’s defence contained sufficient details demanding that Darling prove he is a copyright holder and that these rights have been breached, ruled that the government must within 21 days of the verdict “clarify” its opposition to the claim.
The Court said that the government specify which of the letters Darling purportedly received from an unnamed former prime minister and various agencies, allegedly affirming the copyright of his design, are “fraudulent” in the government’s eyes.
The late Reverend Dr Hervis Bain has always been regarded as the creator of the Bahamian national flag and coat of arms.
But Darling’s claim is based on events that took place almost 60 years ago when his elder sister, Carolyn Ann Esther Storr-Darling, allegedly wrote to the Attorney General’s Office and other government agencies on January 2, 1964, on her then 10-year-old brother’s behalf seeking protection for the board game he had designed, Fun in The Bahamas.
In his statement of claim, Darling alleges that the government confirmed receipt of his sister’s letter on February 3, 1964, and “granted permission…. to copyright the said design”.
Darling is also arguing that the Bahamian national flag “shares similarity” to his Fun in The Bahamas board game design, being “painted the exact colours” with the “same shape and/or layout of the said design”.
He alleges that the government used his design for the national flag without first obtaining his “license or permission” – thereby committing a breach of copyright.
He said in his claim that the government has acknowledged his copyright and ownership of the design on several occasions, dating back to March 3, 1989, when the government gave written confirmation that “a search was conducted brought by James Alexander Darling and has found him to be the first inventor and designer of Fun in The Bahamas, the design for the flag of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas”.
Darling’s claim alleges that his copyright to the Fun in The Bahamas design was further affirmed by April 25, 2012, correspondence from the government, which on April 19, 2016, also confirmed it was holding his sister’s original January 2, 1964, letter.
“The plaintiff made numerous attempts to renew the copyright to the said design but was refused by the defendants [the Attorney General’s Office] and or their agents with no reason given.”
Darling took legal action after the government refused to meet or pay his November 5, 2019, demand for US$42 million in damages “due to the illegal and unauthorised use” of his allegedly copyrighted design that is still in use as the Bahamian national flag.
He is now seeking US$328.5 million in compensation, plus an injunction to block the government from using or reproducing his design without permission. He also wants to be named as the original designer, and wants an inquiry into potential damages.
But the government has refuted all the allegations made by Darling and in in its amended October 27, 2021 response, said “it is the defendant’s position that the purported correspondence relied on by the plaintiff is not authored by the defendant and/or its agents and the same being falsely uttered to a government and/or judicial official knowing the same to be false”.
In its move to have the claim struck out, the government relied on the Crown Proceedings Act, but the judge said invoking the legislation now was “clearly an abuse of process”ruling also that section five (1) and (2) clauses do “not act as a blanket prohibition” against bringing legal actions against the government for copyright violations.
But he noted that “the defendant seems to simply be requiring the plaintiff to prove that the sister of the plaintiff sent in any letters in January 1964 seeking to register the designs of the subject game, and that the plaintiff is in fact the owner of a copyright to the game Fun in The Bahamas, as well as to prove the flag of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas does as a matter of fact infringe the copyright of the plaintiff, if such copyright is found to exist.
“These are matters which must be determined at trial following the usual process of discovery, witness statements and cross-examination. I therefore do not accept that the defence consists solely of bare denials with no way of understanding the defence of the defendant.
“However, I do accept that some clarity could be brought to this matter by specifying which correspondence is alleged to be fraudulent, which would have the effect of clarifying whether the various pieces of correspondence from the plaintiff to the servants of the defendant were in fact received, but the effect of that correspondence is disputed or whether the defence says the correspondence was not received.”
Justice Brathwaite has given the government three weeks from November 24, 2023, to file an amended defence clarifying “which of the correspondence is alleged to be fraudulent and what exactly is being contended with respect to the remainder”
CMC/gf/ir/2023
