·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

CCJ upholds validity of disputed will

3 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Dec 15, CMC – The Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) Friday upheld the validity of a will setting aside the decision of the Court of Appeal and restoring the judgment of the High Court in Guyana.

Guyanese businessman, Yusuf Mongroo, had in his will, appointed his business manager, Sasedai Persaud, as executor, and made her the principal beneficiary. His common-law wife, Indranie Mulchand, also benefitted under the will.

The will was made a few days before his death and was challenged by his daughters, Sherene Mongroo and Zenobia Rosenberg, who did not receive any benefit under the will.

During the hearing at the High Court, the trial judge found that Mongroo’s will was valid and effective, and approved for probate purposes. The copy of the will was put into evidence during the trial.

But the Court of Appeal reversed the decision and the will was held to be invalid and ineffective.

However, in a  judgment authored by Justice Rajnauth-Lee, the CCJ first considered whether conflicting opinions delivered in the Court of Appeal, on certain issues, resulted in a defective judgment on those issues, that should be set aside.

The five member CCJ panel of judges, including its Presidet, Justice Adrian Saunders, underscored that in its Appellate Jurisdiction, it is a superior court of record with such jurisdiction and powers as are conferred on it by the agreement establishing the CCJ, the Constitution or any other law of the Contracting Party.

Accordingly, the CCJ, which is Guyana’s highest and final court,  noted that it was empowered in an appeal from Guyana to ensure the determination on the merits of the real question in controversy between the parties. For that reason, the CCJ did not agree with the submission that the conflicting opinions of the Court of Appeal resulted in a defective judgment that ought to be set aside. The CCJ was, therefore, able to hear the case on its merits and proceeded to do so.

Additionally, before embarking on the issues which largely concerned findings of fact made by the trial judge, the CCJ explained that where a trial judge had properly utilised the distinct advantage of having seen and heard the witnesses, had adequately evaluated the witnesses, and weighed the facts and circumstances of the case, an appellate court ought not to lightly reverse findings of credibility arrived at by the trial judge.

On the issue of whether Mongroo had the required testamentary capacity, the CCJ found that there were no circumstances that should have aroused the suspicion of the trial judge in this case.

In particular, the CCJ noted that the trial judge accepted the evidence of attorney Vidyanand Persaud, who prepared the will, and of Dr Rohan Jabour, a medical doctor, who was one of the witnesses to the will.

The trial judge also found that the daughters had not established that they enjoyed a close relationship with their father.

The CCJ, therefore, held that the evidence accepted by the trial judge provided a sufficient basis on which she could have found that Mungroo had the requisite testamentary capacity.

Regarding certain formality requirements in section 4 of the Wills Act, the CCJ noted  that the will was not signed in the presence of the witnesses, as stated in the attestation clause, that part of a will that has the signature of the person making the will and the witnesses. Consequently, the presumption of due execution could not be applied. However, the Court was of the view that having regard to the evidence accepted by the trial judge, and in particular, the evidence of Dr Jabour, the trial judge’s finding that Mongroo acknowledged his signature on the will in the presence of both witnesses, who signed in his presence, and of each other, could not be faulted.

The Court, therefore, held that due execution of the will had been established.

The CCJ ruled that the trial judge considered the evidence of the two expert witnesses who examined the will  and therefore found that the trial judge was correct to find that the signature on the will was that of Mongroo.

CMc/fg/ir/2023