·  Bridgetown, Barbados

The Caribbean’s independent wire service since 1976.

Subscribe

CCJ upholds insurer’s decision to avoid policy of insurance

3 min read

PORT OF SPAIN, Trinidad, Jan 23, CMC – The Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has dismissed an appeal by a restaurant in Barbados against an insurance company that had refused to honour its obligations after a fire destroyed the business in August 2007.

The appeal had been brought by Apsara Restaurants (Barbados) Limited against the  Guardian General Insurance Limited in the Appellate Jurisdiction,with the CCJ, which serves as the island’s final court, dismissing the appeal and upholding key decisions of the Court of Appeal and the High Court  of Barbados.

The appeal was brought by Apsara Restaurants (Barbados) Limited (Apsara), a company with Sharif Mohammed and his wife, Marie Kavanagh, as sole directors and shareholders.

The court heard that on August 27,  2007, a fire destroyed Apsara’s restaurant premises and that the owners lodged a claim on a fire insurance policy it had entered into with the insurance company in relation to the burnt premises.

Guardian resisted the claim on several grounds. The main grounds surrounded the allegations that Mohammed was responsible for the fire and that in proposing for the insurance coverage, Apsara did not disclose several material facts and thereby induced Guardian to effect the coverage on the premises.

The other ground is that Apsara was in breach of ‘Condition 11’ of the policy to provide Guardian with particulars of loss incurred due to the fire within 15 days of the incident.

The trial judge found for Guardian on each of these points and the Court of Appeal dismissed Apsara’s appeal, ruling that it found no reason to disturb any of the findings of fact or law made by the trial judge.

In its split ruling, the CCJ, by a majority, held that it was entitled to review the concurrent findings of fact of the trial judge and the Court of Appeal. The Court also held Mohammed was responsible for setting the fire.

It was held by all six CCJ judges ultimately deliberating on the case, that given the extenuating circumstances revealed by the evidence, Apsara’s failure to provide particulars of loss within the time stipulated under Clause 11 did not entitle Guardian to avoid the policy of insurance.

The CCJ reasoned that Guardian’s conduct amounted to a waiver of the requirement for strict compliance with Clause 11.

The CCJ discussed at length what was the appropriate test to determine whether a non-disclosure by an insured in an insurance proposal was material. The bench was evenly divided as to the applicable test.

Notwithstanding this, all six judges were satisfied that Apsara had engaged in a material non-disclosure when it failed to disclose to Guardian that O’Meara Food Products Ltd (‘O’Meara’), a company of which Mohammed and Kavanagh also served as sole directors and shareholders, had previously made an unsuccessful claim on an insurance policy.

The Court also considered that there was material non-disclosure by Apsara when it failed to disclose that a judgment had been registered against O’Meara, Mohammed, and Kavanagh, jointly and severally, in favour of the Agricultural Development Bank of Trinidad and Tobago to the tune of TT$ 1,060,075.19 (One TT dollar=US$0.16 cents).

The Court said it also considered that such material non-disclosures entitled Guardian to avoid its policy of insurance with Apsara.

CMC/af/ir/2024